In: Chemistry
Which reagent(s) may be used to distinguish between each of the following pairs of compounds? Select a test that gives positive results with one compound of the pair and negative results with the other compound.Explain what will be observed in each case.
(a) 1-butanol and butanal
(b) toluene and acetophenone
(a) Use Tollens reagent
The reagent consists of a solution of silver nitrate and ammonia. A positive test on butanal with Tollens reagent is indicated by the precipitation of elemental silver, often producing a characteristic "silver mirror" on the inner surface of the reaction vessel. The diamminesilver(I) complex oxidizes the aldehyde to a carboxylate ion and in the process is reduced to elemental silver and aqueous ammonia.
The ionic equation of the overall reaction is shown below where R refers to an alkyl group.
2 [Ag(NH3)2]+ + RCHO + H2O → 2 Ag(s) + 4 NH3 + RCO2H + 2 H+
(Silver mirror)
(b) Use DNPH, Brady's reagent
2,4-Dinitrophenylhydrazine (DNPH) is a red to orange solid with chemical formula C6H3(NO2)2NHNH2. It can be used to qualitatively detect the carbonyl functionality of a ketone or an aldehyde functional group. A positive test on acetophenone is indicated by a red precipitate (known as a dinitrophenylhydrazone.).
The reaction between 2,4-Dinitrophenylhydrazine and a ketone is shown below:
RR'C=O + C6H3(NO2)2NHNH2 → C6H3(NO2)2NHNCRR' + H2O
(Red ppt.)