In: Finance
1. question
What does the accounting rate of return measure?
2. question
Which of the following is an advantage of using the payback period?
3. question
Alternative projects, X and Y, have been evaluated and the following results found:
| 
 Project X  | 
 Project Y  | 
|
| 
 Payback period  | 
 3.1 years  | 
 3.5 years  | 
| 
 Accounting rate of return  | 
 17%  | 
 21%  | 
| 
 Net Present Value  | 
 $385,000  | 
 $481,000  | 
Which of the following is the most valid reason for choosing to undertake project Y?
Question 1) Answer: B. The average annual expected profit
expressed as a percentage of the average funds invested in
it.
Accounting rate of return = Average net profit/Average
investment.
Option A & C, expectes total profit, but the ARR will use
average net profit, hence option A & C are wrong
Option D, express percentage of initial outlay, but actual ARR will
use average investment hence this option also wrong.
Question 2) Answer: B. It is useful measure of the speed with
which a project will pay back its initial costs.
Followings are the disadvantages of payback period:
- It ignores the actual timing of cash flows.
- It takes no account of the time value of money.
- It ignores cash inflows after the payback point has been
reached.
Only option B is the advantage of payback period.
Question 3) Answer: C. Project Y will yield the highest
NPV.
Longer payback period we will not select, so option B is not
suitable.
Option A ignores the actual cashflow from the project, hence it may
mislead.