Question

Problem 12-23 Make or Buy Decision [LO12-3]

Silven Industries, which manufactures and sells a highly successful line of summer lotions and insect repellents, has decided to diversify in order to stabilize sales throughout the year. A natural area for the company to consider is the production of winter lotions and creams to prevent dry and chapped skin.

After considerable research, a winter products line has been developed. However, Silven’s president has decided to introduce only one of the new products for this coming winter. If the product is a success, further expansion in future years will be initiated.

The product selected (called Chap-Off) is a lip balm that will be sold in a lipstick-type tube. The product will be sold to wholesalers in boxes of 24 tubes for $10 per box. Because of excess capacity, no additional fixed manufacturing overhead costs will be incurred to produce the product. However, a $128,000 charge for fixed manufacturing overhead will be absorbed by the product under the company’s absorption costing system.

Using the estimated sales and production of 160,000 boxes of Chap-Off, the Accounting Department has developed the following manufacturing cost per box:

Direct material	$	4.50
Direct labor		2.80
Manufacturing overhead		2.00
Total cost	$	9.30

The costs above relate to making both the lip balm and the tube that contains it. As an alternative to making the tubes for Chap-Off, Silven has approached a supplier to discuss the possibility of buying the tubes. The purchase price of the supplier's empty tubes would be $1.40 per box of 24 tubes. If Silven Industries stops making the tubes and buys them from the outside supplier, its direct labor and variable manufacturing overhead costs per box of Chap-Off would be reduced by 10% and its direct materials costs would be reduced by 20%.

Required:

1. If Silven buys its tubes from the outside supplier, how much of its own Chap-Off manufacturing costs per box will it be able to avoid? (Hint: You need to separate the manufacturing overhead of $2.00 per box that is shown above into its variable and fixed components to derive the correct answer.)

2. What is the financial advantage (disadvantage) per box of Chap-Off if Silven buys its tubes from the outside supplier?

3. What is the financial advantage (disadvantage) in total (not per box) if Silven buys 160,000 boxes of tubes from the outside supplier?

4. Should Silven Industries make or buy the tubes?

5. What is the maximum price that Silven should be willing to pay the outside supplier for a box of 24 tubes?

6. Instead of sales of 160,000 boxes of tubes, revised estimates show a sales volume of 197,000 boxes of tubes. At this higher sales volume, Silven would need to rent extra equipment at a cost of $57,000 per year to make the additional 37,000 boxes of tubes. Assuming that the outside supplier will not accept an order for less than 197,000 boxes of tubes, what is the financial advantage (disadvantage) in total (not per box) if Silven buys 197,000 boxes of tubes from the outside supplier? Given this new information, should Silven Industries make or buy the tubes?

7. Refer to the data in (6) above. Assume that the outside supplier will accept an order of any size for the tubes at a price of $1.40 per box. How many boxes of tubes should Silven make? How many boxes of tubes should it buy from the outside supplier?

If Silven buys its tubes from the outside supplier, how much of its own Chap-Off manufacturing costs per box will it be able to avoid? (Hint: You need to separate the manufacturing overhead of $2.00 per box that is shown above into its variable and fixed components to derive the correct answer.) (Do not round intermediate calculations. Round your answer to 2 decimal places.)

Show less

	Avoidable manufacturing costs per box of Chap-Off

What is the financial advantage (disadvantage) per box of Chap-Off if Silven buys its tubes from the outside supplier? (Do not round intermediate calculations. Round your answer to 2 decimal places.)

	per box

What is the financial advantage (disadvantage) in total (not per box) if Silven buys 160,000 boxes of tubes from the outside supplier?

• Req

Should Silven Industries make or buy the tubes?

make or buy

What is the maximum price that Silven should be willing to pay the outside supplier for a box of 24 tubes? (Do not round intermediate calculations. Round your answer to 2 decimal places.)

	Maximum price per box

Instead of sales of 160,000 boxes of tubes, revised estimates show a sales volume of 197,000 boxes of tubes. At this higher sales volume, Silven would need to rent extra equipment at a cost of $57,000 per year to make the additional 37,000 boxes of tubes. Assuming that the outside supplier will not accept an order for less than 197,000 boxes of tubes, what is the financial advantage (disadvantage) in total (not per box) if Silven buys 197,000 boxes of tubes from the outside supplier? Given this new information, should Silven Industries make or buy the tubes?

Show less

	Make or buy the boxes of tubes?

Refer to the data in (6) above. Assume that the outside supplier will accept an order of any size for the tubes at a price of $1.40 per box. How many boxes of tubes should Silven make? How many boxes of tubes should it buy from the outside supplier? (Round your intermediate calculations to 2 decimal places.)

	Number of boxes of tubes manufactured by Silven Number of boxes of tubes purchased from the outside supplier

Answer 1

Answer:

Answer No.	Particulars	Amount
1	Avoidable Direct Materials Cost ($ 4.5 * 0.2)	$          0.90
	Avoidable Direct Labor Cost ($ 2.8 * 0.1)	$          0.28
	Avoidable Variable Manufacturing Overhead ($ 2 - $ 0.8) * 0.1	$          0.12
	Total cost avoided	$          1.30
	So,
	Avoidable Chap-Off manufacturing costs	$          1.30
2	Avoidable Chap-Off manufacturing costs (from answer 1)	$          1.30
	Purchase Price	$          1.40
	Net loss	$          0.10
	So,
	Financial disadvantage = $ 0.1 per box.
3	Financial disadvantage per box	$          0.10
	Number of Boxes	160,000
	Financial disadvantage in total	$      16,000
4	Silven industries should MAKE the tubes.
5	The maximum prices that Silven industries will be willing to pay to the outside supplier will be equal to the total cost it can avoid from purchasing the tubes from the supplier.
	So,
	Maximum Price	$          1.30
6	Cost of making (197000 * $ 1.3) + $ 57000	$    313,100
	Purchase cost incurred (197000 * $ 1.4)	$    275,800
	Financial advantage	$      37,300
	The company should BUY the tubes.
7	Tubes that the company should make	160,000
	Tubes that the company should buy (197000 - 160000)	37,000

In case of any doubt or clarification, feel free to come back via comments.