Question

In: Physics

Consider an animal like a horse. Now scale its neck longer and longer. How can a...

Consider an animal like a horse. Now scale its neck longer and longer.

How can a giraffe, or even worse a huge dinosaur, raise its neck without the tendons snapping? The dinosaur case in particular seems ridiculous. Is there a "physics trick" the animals use to make this more manageable? Or does the tendon tension not scale as badly as my intuitiion is claiming?

Solutions

Expert Solution

Let's scale up an animal.

If length is , and we don't change the proportions, then the mass of the head+neck will scale as . If the neck & head are being held horizontally, the lever arm scales as , so the torque at the base of the neck scales as .

The width of the neck scales as , so the force on the tendons/muscles scales as . The yield strength of a tendon/muscle scales with its cross-sectional area: .

The force is going as , but the yield strength is going as . My math agrees with your intuition: as you make an animal bigger, eventually the neck won't be able to handle the stress.

The reason why the giraffe can get away with long necks is twofold, I'd guess:

1) They have a proportionally thicker neck. Look at a picture of giraffe. Note that the neck gets extremely thick toward the base along the front-to-back axis (which is the the axis along which they lower their head), while it's slender side-to-side. Of course, this you can only change proportions so far: eventually the animal will be all neck.

2) We've got a lot of overhead with our short human necks. Ferinstance, I can support weights much heavier than my head with my arms, despite my arms being much longer AND a bit thinner than my neck.


Related Solutions

Identify a product that has gone away (like horse and buggy) and identify its current replacement...
Identify a product that has gone away (like horse and buggy) and identify its current replacement (automobile). Discuss in detail why the market (made up of consumer and business buyers AND other sellers) has pushed out the old product and brought in the current replacement - consider/identify/discuss the "features," "attributes," and "benefits" (FAB) of the current replacement product that provide GREATER utility than the FAB delivered by the old product. For the product that is the current replacement, also forecast...
Can Tesla Achieve Economies of Scale and Keep its Promise?
Can Tesla Achieve Economies of Scale and Keep its Promise?
In how many ways can a five horse race end, allowing for the possibility that two...
In how many ways can a five horse race end, allowing for the possibility that two horses tie?
Now consider the set of portfolios that can be obtained by combining the stock and the...
Now consider the set of portfolios that can be obtained by combining the stock and the bond. Please show your detailed calculations or provide arguments to support your answers Allocation to Stock Allocation to Bond Portfolio Mean Portfolio Std Dev 0% 100% 10.0% 10.00% 25% 75% 11.25% 10.55% 50% 50% 12.50% 12.85% 75% 25% 13.75% 16.17% 100% 0% 15.0% 20.00% a. What percentage of your wealth is allocated in the stock and bond at the minimum variance portfolio? b. What...
Consider the standard Keynesian ISLM model of the economy. a.    How does a change in animal...
Consider the standard Keynesian ISLM model of the economy. a.    How does a change in animal spirits which inspires fear of investment effect ISLM? b.    How does this effect the aggregate demand and supply? c.    What will happen to the level of output and price level in the short run and in the long run? d.    Illustrate the above process by deriving the IS and LM before and after the shock, showing the change in aggregate demand and/or aggregate supply,...
Can somebody write a one page essay on why they like Chinese art and how its...
Can somebody write a one page essay on why they like Chinese art and how its important to you? From your own perspective don't copy and paste from a website
How is learning by doing related to the concept of economies of scale? Can a firm...
How is learning by doing related to the concept of economies of scale? Can a firm enjoy cost savings from both?
How is learning by doing related to the concept of economies of scale? Can a firm...
How is learning by doing related to the concept of economies of scale? Can a firm enjoy cost savings from both?
Which class of arthropods is the most diverse animal group on the planet? How can this...
Which class of arthropods is the most diverse animal group on the planet? How can this evolutionary success be explained?
Your consulting company is now working with another company that would like to expand its business...
Your consulting company is now working with another company that would like to expand its business into other countries. You have been asked to provide a comparison of the different economic systems and how the company would need to operate in each country. Select two countries and write a 525- to 700-word paper in which you: Compare the economic systems of the two countries and their impact on business growth/development. Identify the major economic/political systems of each country. Discuss which...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT