Question

In: Physics

I was doing some reading on wikipedia and found it interesting that one page says the...

I was doing some reading on wikipedia and found it interesting that one page says the Grand Canonical Ensemble does not allow for exchange of particles, however another page says it does. So I went on google books and tried to look for a more trust worthy source, again the same happens one source says it allows the other says it doesn't so which is it?

Book that says it does allow exchange: http://www.scribd.com/doc/52426748/46/Grand-Canonical-Ensemble

Another that says it isn't allowed: http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=5sd9SAoRjgQC&pg=PA62&dq=grand+canonical+ensemble+exchange+particles&hl=en&ei=hL6oTZ2THc_p4wbEh-3DCg&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=1&ved=0CC0Q6AEwAA#v=onepage&q=grand%20canonical%20ensemble%20exchange%20particles&f=false

What gives?

Solutions

Expert Solution

There are, essentially, three types of ensembles used in thermodynamics:

Microcanonical Ensemble: This is used to describe closed systems. The number of particles and the total energy are constant (since no interaction with the environment takes place). In such a system, the entropy will eventually be maximized.
Canonical Ensemble: Now, your system is in contact with a big reservoir and allowed to exchange energy with the system. This means that your system will be in thermal equilibrium with the bath.
Grand Canonical Ensemble Now, your system can exchange both energy and particles with the system. Hence, it will be in thermal equilibrium with the bath and in chemical equilibrium, i.e. the chemical potential for adding a particle to your system equals the chemical potential for adding a particle to the bath.

If exchanging particles wasn't allowed in the grand canonical ensemble, it would become the canonical ensemble.


Related Solutions

I was reading my textbook and it says that breathing involves inhaling and exhaling but it...
I was reading my textbook and it says that breathing involves inhaling and exhaling but it doesn't say whether they happen simultaneously or sequentially. Also is my overall understanding of breathing competent? When you breathe in air, air ends up in the lungs passing through the nasal passages (heated, moistened, cleaned) through the pharynx, through the glottis through the larynx, through the trachea and into the bronchi and then into the bronchioles. Once air gets to the lungs, Is their...
Follow this link to the Wikipedia page describing the Asian Financial Crisis (I have crossed referenced...
Follow this link to the Wikipedia page describing the Asian Financial Crisis (I have crossed referenced the data on Wikipedia for accuracy and have found the information to be correct). Many of the Asian Tigers (Singapore, Malaysia, South Korea, Thailand, Hong Kong, Taiwan, etc.) blamed the downturn of their economies on currency traders. Malaysia and Thailand took drastic measures to clamp down on trading in the Thai baht and the Malaysian ringgit as well as foreign direct investment in their...
I found the discussion of self constructed assets to be interesting. These would be assets that...
I found the discussion of self constructed assets to be interesting. These would be assets that the company itself builds instead of buys. The book talks about the difficulties in establishing the cost of the asset. How much of the company's overhead should be allocated to the project? How should interest incurred during construction be handled? There are a few options/opinions about how to handle overhead, which do you find to be best?
Find a country that has some interesting financial laws regulations or practices that can make doing...
Find a country that has some interesting financial laws regulations or practices that can make doing business there a challenge. Discuss how imports and exports differ from the U.S. standards.
I just need some guidance on how i should go about doing this. Now choose one...
I just need some guidance on how i should go about doing this. Now choose one of your firms and look up other firms in the same industry. (pick any) Perform a “Valuation by Comparables” analysis by looking at the price/earnings, price/book value, price/sales, and price/operating cash flow ratios of the firms relative to each other and to the industry average. Which of the firms seem to be overvalued? Which seem to be undervalued? Can you think of reasons for...
Select one concept that you found interesting and describe it in detail for critical thinking in...
Select one concept that you found interesting and describe it in detail for critical thinking in nursing . Describe how you would use this concept in practice.
I am having an error in this function. It says Max was not found. int height()...
I am having an error in this function. It says Max was not found. int height() const {    if (is_null()) return 0; return 1 + max(get_left_subtree().height(), get_right_subtree().height()); } The whole code is #ifndef BINARY_TREE_H #define BINARY_TREE_H #include <cstddef> #include <sstream> #include <stdexcept> #include <string> #include <algorithm> #include "BTNode.h" template<typename Item_Type> class Binary_Tree { public: Binary_Tree() : root(NULL) {} Binary_Tree(const Item_Type& the_data, const Binary_Tree<Item_Type>& left_child = Binary_Tree(), const Binary_Tree<Item_Type>& right_child = Binary_Tree()) : root(new BTNode<Item_Type>(the_data, left_child.root, right_child.root)) {} virtual ~Binary_Tree()...
SWOT analysis for Wikipedia I need some more thoughts to add: S free for all to...
SWOT analysis for Wikipedia I need some more thoughts to add: S free for all to use W not credible sources for schools O provide peer reviewed articles T lack of volunteers downturn of donations
I require some assistance with the following assignment as I belive I might be doing it...
I require some assistance with the following assignment as I belive I might be doing it wrong especially in step 2. Your assistance is much appreciated. Linux Shell Scripting Practice: Note: The following excercise requires the use of the nano text editor. Begin by starting a script called “m5a2_part2b” by issuing the following at the command in a open terminal: $ script m5a2_part2b Step 1: Using the nano text editor, edit the following “Hello World” program, save as hello.sh, change...
Hi, I have a question. I am doing Preminary Analytical Procedure for Apollo Shoes. I found...
Hi, I have a question. I am doing Preminary Analytical Procedure for Apollo Shoes. I found unusual percentage for Line of Credit( increased to 344%) and Accounts Payable decreased by 59%. Is this cause RMM increase? I have hard time understanding this project. Please help me. Thanks.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT