Question

In: Physics

in recent questions like "How are classical optics phenomena explained in QED (Snell's law)?" and "Do...

in recent questions like "How are classical optics phenomena explained in QED (Snell's law)?" and "Do photons gain mass when they travel through glass?" we could learn something about effective properties of matter interacting with a force field in terms of the path integral and quasiparticles.

Surely, both approaches must be equivalent but come from a different philosophy. Widely used is the quasiparticle approach in solid state physics e.g. calculating dispersion relations of phonons.

I would really like to know if there are simple examples for explicit calculations of the properties of photon-quasiparticles coming from a rigorous approach like a matter description via QED and finding an effective action e.g. using the Wetterich equation (see e.g. Introduction to the functional RG and applications to gauge theories).

Any calculations and/or references would be very nice.
Thank you in advance, sincerely,

Solutions

Expert Solution

The quasiparticle description of photons is well known in condensed matter physics as the frequency dependent complex dielectric constant/magnetic-permeability of a material. You are asking if this quantity can be calculated from QED by a first principles method.

This seems less difficult compared to other quasiparticles, because the photon usually stays noninteracting in the medium at ordinary temperatures, except for the absorption and dispersion. There is a mismatch of scale between the photon frequency/wavelength and other quasiparticles, which travel much slower than light. Even so, I didn't find many papers adressing this question, because we have good measurements of the dielectric constant as a function of frequency for any material. The material is doing the calculation for you.

For dilute gasses, Feynman adresses the question of calculating the dielectric constant from a first principles calculation in his 1963 Acta Physica Polonica article which introduced ghost fields. The frequency dependent dielectric constant is determined from the scattering phase shift in the forward direction, which reproduces the qualitative behavior of even crazy cases like when you pass an atomic resonance. The reference is below.

  • RP Feynman, Acta Physica Polonica, 24 (1963) 697

Some classic reference for QED in media, which include calculations of the effects of dielectric properties at finite frequencies, are these original papers:

  • E. M. Lifshitz,

Related Solutions

What phenomena can be explained using a wave model of light? Do this carefully and thoroughly....
What phenomena can be explained using a wave model of light? Do this carefully and thoroughly. Be sure to state what property of the wave model leads to the explanation it provides. Link this property to the ray and Huygen’s diagrams you draw. DRAW DIAGRAM
A) Explain how adherents to Say’s law explained the relationship between savings and investment and the...
A) Explain how adherents to Say’s law explained the relationship between savings and investment and the behavior of wages and prices. B) What was Keynes’s criticism of Say’s law?
how do you use the law of cosines to calculate the angles for like roof trusses...
how do you use the law of cosines to calculate the angles for like roof trusses provide an example
How do you address this situation with the professional who explained the situation?
 Read the Case Study of "Becky" on page 63 of your textbook: Theories, Practice, and Trends in Human Services Practice. Based upon the human services code of ethics, you are the supervisor of the human services professional who Becky confided in. How do you address this situation with the professional who explained the situation? In your answer, which model discussed in this lecture would be more appropriate and effective to use in this situation? State your reasons why.
What is the difference between groupthink, group polarization and groupshift? How do these phenomena influence the...
What is the difference between groupthink, group polarization and groupshift? How do these phenomena influence the consensus-building process in a group decision-making situation?
Explain each of the questions in 10 lines: 1-Geometric Optics 2-How to generate Spherical Waves (light)....
Explain each of the questions in 10 lines: 1-Geometric Optics 2-How to generate Spherical Waves (light). 3-Reflection of light and applications 4-The angles related to Reflection and Plane Mirrors
In the current unprecedented business climate, how do think this “economic phenomenon” will be explained to...
In the current unprecedented business climate, how do think this “economic phenomenon” will be explained to accounting , economic and finance students in the future.How do YOU think it will affect the future education of business disciplines (accounting, economics, and finance) in the future?
In the current unprecedented business climate, how do think this “economic phenomenon” will be explained to...
In the current unprecedented business climate, how do think this “economic phenomenon” will be explained to accounting , economic and finance students in the future. please explain in your own words.
How does the classical/neoclassical theory’s “Say’s Law” (or the saving-investment mechanism) suggest that the economy will...
How does the classical/neoclassical theory’s “Say’s Law” (or the saving-investment mechanism) suggest that the economy will adjust when a demand-side “shock” caused by a decline in consumption spending occurs? Why did Keynes believe (and why do many economists still believe) that these adjustments will not occur? Answer both of these questions with regard to a demand-side “shock” caused by a decline in investment spending.   
Questions How is monopolistic competition like monopoly? How is it like perfect competition? Draw a diagram...
Questions How is monopolistic competition like monopoly? How is it like perfect competition? Draw a diagram depicting a firm that is making a profit in a monopolistically competitive market. In the long-run, do monopolistically competitive firms produce the socially optimal quantity of their product? Why or why not? Why is advertising important in monopolistically competitive markets, but not in perfectly competitive or monopolistic markets? There are four basic solutions to handling monopolies: 1. Break it up (through anti-trust laws); 2....
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT