Question

Kalamazoo College requires all computers connected to the campus network be running up-to-date antivirus software. When a student’s computer is discovered to have a virus, its network connection is cut until a staff member can remove the virus. If it turns out that the computer was not running up-to-date antivirus software, the student is fined $100. Is this a morally justifiable policy?

Answer 1

As all computers running in the Kalamazoo College are interconnected in the campus, so we should keep in mind that any virus in any computer system may harm the entire computer network. The college data, important records of students etc. will always be at risk in the absence of anti-virus software. Antivirus software is essential for keeping the PC running safely. It’s vital that students should keep their PC’s protection up to date; otherwise newer threats may be able to slip past and spread in the entire computer network.

It is necessary to constantly update the anti-virus software on a computer system because computers are frequently threatened by new viruses. The anti-virus updates contain the newest files needed to battle new viruses and protect the computer. Antivirus software protects the computer from incoming threats and seeks out, kills and warns of possible threats to the system. New viruses are coming out regularly all the time. It is the task of the antivirus software to keep up with the latest threats.

Now lets come to the core i.e. “Is this a morally justifiable policy to fine a student $100 for not running up-to-date antivirus software”

Morally it is a not justifiable policy but keeping in mind the security of the other computers it is suggested that

1. Regular workshops should be organized by the college regarding anti-virus software .
2. In the first case warning should be given to students for not installing the anti-virus software instead of cutting the internet connection.
3. A reasonable amount may be charged from the student if he deliberately not installing the anti-virus software.