Question

In: Economics

Compare and contrast the strengths and weaknesses of fiscal policy and monetary policy.

Compare and contrast the strengths and weaknesses of fiscal policy and monetary policy.

Solutions

Expert Solution

The monetary policy is the function of the Federal Reserve Board of Governors, currently led by Alan Greenspan, to control the money supply. One of the Federal Reserve System's key duties is to control money supply so as to sustain steady demand, prices and employment. The "Fed" has three tools for controlling the money supply. They are the prerequisite for reserves, free market operations and the discount rate.

The reserve provision is the most powerful resource available. The reserve allowance is the amount of capital the bank can't lend out. If it is reduced, banks are forced to hold less money, and so more money is put into circulation. If it is increased, then banks may need to obtain some loans to fulfill the new demand for reserve.

The tool known as open market operations influences money and credit operations through the open market purchasing and selling of government securities. This is used for the control of the total supply of capital. If the Fed believes there isn't enough money in circulation, then member banks will buy the securities. If the Fed thinks the economy has too much liquidity, they'll sell the securities back to the banks. Since it is easier to make radical adjustments to the money supply, free market operations are used more frequently than monetary policy.

If member banks want to raise money, Federal Reserve Banks will borrow it. Just like other loans, the third tool of monetary policy is an interest rate, or a discount rate. If the discount rate is high, then fewer banks will be inclined to borrow, and if it is low, more banks will borrow from the reserve banks (theoretically). The discount rate is not used as much as it was in the past, but it does serve as an indication of the Fed's intentions to limit or expand the money supply to private bankers.

Monetary policy is a powerful way to control the supply of money but it has its drawbacks. One downside is that tight policy on money works better than loose policy on money. Tight government works to get government in and avoid inflation, but people have to want loans and want to invest money to get loose policies to actually work. Monetary velocity is another problem. The number of times a dollar changes hands for goods and services each year is entirely independent of money supply, and may often contradict the Fed's efforts. The benefits of the monetary system are that it can be introduced with timely results instantly.

The second way of controlling the money supply lies with the Fiscal Policy in government hands. Fiscal policy is made up of two principal instruments. Changing tax rates, and government spending rising. The key point of fiscal policy is to reduce the economy's surplus / deficit fluctuations by rising inflation and recession. If inflation is unusually high, a increase in tax levels is generally introduced, and high unemployment recession occurs. Taxes increase with high inflation, so that people have less to spend, thereby reducing demand and inflation. During a high-unemployment crisis, taxes are reduced to give more people money to spend and thereby raise demand for goods and services, and the economy is starting to recover.

A rise in government spending impacts the economy more profoundly than a change in tax rates. When the government wants to fight a recession, it will invest a large amount of money on goods and services, all of which are released into the economy.

It does have disadvantages, despite the Fiscal Policy 's effectiveness. The main problems are pacing and politics. Inflation and recession can be hard to foresee, so it can be a long period of time before the condition is even noticed. Because a tax cut can take a year to actually come into effect, the economy could recover from the recession and the new unnecessary tax cut could lead to inflation.

Politics is just another problem. Unlike the conservative Fed 's monetary policy , the government implements fiscal policy, and so politics plays a key role in the program. By observing the government's issues, it becomes clear that a balanced budget is not the primary goal, anyway. Fiscal policies can also be used as strategies for campaigning. When tax cuts are introduced and government spending decreases, then the president is more likely to be re-elected but first has to deal with the inflation generated by his policy.


Related Solutions

Compare and contrast Fiscal Policy and Monetary Policy. -How does each policy handle the two major...
Compare and contrast Fiscal Policy and Monetary Policy. -How does each policy handle the two major macroeconomic failures of unemployment and inflation?
5. a) Compare and contrast the inside vs outside lags between monetary and fiscal policy      ...
5. a) Compare and contrast the inside vs outside lags between monetary and fiscal policy       b) What are the pros and cons on the “rule vs discretions” on the     stabilization? What is the ‘monetary rule’ proposed by Milton Friedman? c) Use the following table to set up the ‘rules of monetary growth”       GDP growth inflation nominal GDP current (actual) 3% 4.50% $ 2.3 trillion target    4% 2% $ 2.42 trillion
Compare and contrast the time lag of fiscal and monetary policies. Alternative perspectives on stabilization policy,...
Compare and contrast the time lag of fiscal and monetary policies. Alternative perspectives on stabilization policy, passive vs active, conservative vs liberal, rule vs discretion. Taylor’s rule on monetary policy, i.e. nominal federal fund rate = inflation rate + 2% + ½ (inflation rate minus 2%) + ½ (GDP gap).
Comapre and contrast Monetary policy, with fiscal policy. give 2 examples of each.
Comapre and contrast Monetary policy, with fiscal policy. give 2 examples of each.
Compare fiscal policy with monetary policy. What are they, how are they similar, and how do...
Compare fiscal policy with monetary policy. What are they, how are they similar, and how do they differ? Your answer should consider the role of government deficits (i.e., the national debt) in each and at least touch upon the concepts of "monetizing the debt," "velocity," the "Keynesian multipliers," "crowding out," and "Ricardian equivalence." How does your answer relate to aggregate demand and loanable funds market? What is a liquidity trap?
Compare Monetary policy and Fiscal policy. What is the purpose for using them, and what are...
Compare Monetary policy and Fiscal policy. What is the purpose for using them, and what are the tools used in each? How can either or both be used for achieving macroeconomic goals?
In terms of Macroeconomics, compare and contrast fiscal and monetary policies in terms of their main...
In terms of Macroeconomics, compare and contrast fiscal and monetary policies in terms of their main strengths and weeknesses.
Compare and contrast fiscal policy and monetray policy. is one better than the other? or are...
Compare and contrast fiscal policy and monetray policy. is one better than the other? or are they both necessary? explain fully (include graphs with answer)
Classical, Keynesian and Monetarists view of monetary policy. Compare and contrast these three approaches to monetary...
Classical, Keynesian and Monetarists view of monetary policy. Compare and contrast these three approaches to monetary policy. Include in your analysis if monetary policy is considered effective under all the schools. Moreover, what is the role of money in the economy? What causes inflation?
Compare and contrast: 1) carbon credit system 2) Pigou carbon taxes. Identify the strengths and weaknesses
Compare and contrast: 1) carbon credit system 2) Pigou carbon taxes. Identify the strengths and weaknesses
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT