Question

In: Finance

The Promoter Chairperson of a leading Jewellery chain in Kerala had recently procured a Corporate Jet....

  1. The Promoter Chairperson of a leading Jewellery chain in Kerala had recently procured a Corporate Jet. The purchase price of the Jet is $ 300 million and the pre-tax operational costs of the Jet is $ 50 million per annum. The management of the firm estimates that this asset will be under-utilized. The Jet can be used to fly the management also for important meetings in Mumbai and Delhi, which will reduce the current travel expenses of the management by $ 40 million. However, flying the management along with Chairperson would result in an additional pre-tax operational cost of $ 30 million per annum for the Jet. The management also estimates that this additional activity of flying the management team would force the Jet to be replaced in three years rather than four years, when used only by the Chairperson. Beyond its useful life, the Jet can be sold for $ 100 million, in both the scenarios. The use of corporate Jet is indispensable for the firm and will continue in the future. Assuming the Jet be depreciated using the straight line method to zero book value in both cases, the opportunity cost of capital to be 10%, the corporate tax rate to be 20%, which option should the firm choose?

please solve by formula method and not by excel method

Solutions

Expert Solution

1st option (Jet used only by Chairman for 4 years)

Operating cost per annum= $50 million

Annual Depreciation = $300 million/4 = $75 million

Annual Pre tax cost = $125 million

Annual Post tax cost = $125 million * (1-0.2) = $100 million

Add Depreciation = $75 million

Net annual cost = $25 million

Post tax salvage value in year 4 = $100 million * (1-0.2) = $80 million

So, Equivalent annual cost (EAC) of the option = $300*0.1/(1-1/1.1^4) + $25 - 80*0.1/(1.1^4-1) = $102.40 million

2nd option (Jet used only by both Chairman and management for 3 years)

Normal Operating cost per annum= $50 million

Additional Operating cost per annum= $30 million

Savings per annum = $40 million

Annual Depreciation = $300 million/3 = $100 million

Net Annual Pre tax cost = $140 million

Annual Post tax cost = $140 million * (1-0.2) = $112 million

Add Depreciation = $100 million

Net annual cost = $12 million

Post tax salvage value in year 3 = $100 million * (1-0.2) = $80 million

So, Equivalent annual cost (EAC) of the option = 300*0.1/(1-1/1.1^3) + 12 - 80*0.1/(1.1^3-1) = $108.47 million

As the EAC of the 1st option is only $102.40 million whereas that of the 2nd option is $108.47 million, it means that the 1st option of Jet being used only by Chairman is cheaper and should be selected. So, Jet should be used only by the Chairman


Related Solutions

The Promoter Chairperson of a leading Jewellery chain in Kerala had recently procured a Corporate Jet....
The Promoter Chairperson of a leading Jewellery chain in Kerala had recently procured a Corporate Jet. The purchase price of the Jet is $ 300 million and the pre-tax operational costs of the Jet is $ 50 million per annum. The management of the firm estimates that this asset will be under-utilized. The Jet can be used to fly the management also for important meetings in Mumbai and Delhi, which will reduce the current travel expenses of the management by...
The Promoter Chairperson of a leading Jewellery chain in Kerala had recently procured a Corporate Jet....
The Promoter Chairperson of a leading Jewellery chain in Kerala had recently procured a Corporate Jet. The purchase price of the Jet is $ 300 million and the pre-tax operational costs of the Jet is $ 50 million per annum. The management of the firm estimates that this asset will be under-utilized. The Jet can be used to fly the management also for important meetings in Mumbai and Delhi, which will reduce the current travel expenses of the management by...
May Gems Sdn Bhd is a successful jewellery business. The company was recently bought over by...
May Gems Sdn Bhd is a successful jewellery business. The company was recently bought over by Boon who engages his brother-in-law, Wan, to perform the audit. Wan has experience in auditing small business companies but he has no experience or knowledge with the jewellery or gems business. After completing all the steps of the audit process, Wan issues an unqualified opinion that provides reasonable assurance that the company's financial statements contain no material misstatements. Comment on any potential problems with...
(1) Is a CEO using a corporate jet (instead of flying commercial) a sign of severe...
(1) Is a CEO using a corporate jet (instead of flying commercial) a sign of severe principal-agent problems within a company? Why or why not? (2) Why is this a stark example of the principal-agent problem discussed in Chapter 1?
A music promoter has had an offer to bring a famous musical group from England to...
A music promoter has had an offer to bring a famous musical group from England to Australia, as part of its world tour to promote its new album. The music promoter has done smaller tours previously, but nothing on the scale proposed by the manager of this famous group, the tour will cost several million dollars, but is likely to have revenue which will result in substantial profits for those involved. The promoter has some contacts at a national radio...
urgent Firm Y’s corporate jet is not fully utilized. You estimate that its use by other...
urgent Firm Y’s corporate jet is not fully utilized. You estimate that its use by other officers would increase direct operating costs by only $20,000 a year and would save $90,000 a year in airline bills. However, the increase in usage of the jet will make the firm to replace the jet at the end of three years rather than four. A new jet (at the current low rate of use) has a life of six years, and the equivalent...
You are a corporate Finance manager at penguins plc, a leading operator of domestic waste recycling...
You are a corporate Finance manager at penguins plc, a leading operator of domestic waste recycling and incineration services New legislation on air quality and emissions control means that the company must invest in a new incineration facilities. Two possible investment options have been identified. Each option has an expected life of ten years. Sufficient funding is available to finance only one of the options. option A Option B Initial cost year 0 200,250 210,260 Scrap value year 10 310...
Recently a case of food poisoning was traced to a particular restaurant chain. The source was...
Recently a case of food poisoning was traced to a particular restaurant chain. The source was identified and corrective actions were taken to make sure that the food poisoning would not reoccur. Despite the response from the restaurant chain, many consumers refused to visit the restaurant for some time after the event. A survey was conducted three months after the food poisoning occurred, with a sample of 319 former customers contacted. 29 indicated that they would not go back to...
Various Governements have recently been considering putting limitations on top corporate executive pay and/or taxing corporate...
Various Governements have recently been considering putting limitations on top corporate executive pay and/or taxing corporate executive bonuses very highly (for example, a 70 percent tax rate). What are the implications of this on the market for top executive talent?
​Kroger, the​ country's leading​ grocery-only chain, added a line of private label organic and natural foods...
​Kroger, the​ country's leading​ grocery-only chain, added a line of private label organic and natural foods call Simple Truth to its stores. If​ you've priced organic​ foods, you know they are more expensive. For​ example, a dozen conventionally farmed​ Grade-A eggs at Kroger costs consumers$1.81​,whereas Simple Truth eggs are priced at $4.1 per dozen. One study found​ that, overall, the average price of organic foods is 85 percent more than that of conventional foods.​ However, if prices get too​ high,...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT