Question

In: Operations Management

Business Law Question Alina, a chef who has never owned her own restaurant, sues a builder...

Business Law Question

Alina, a chef who has never owned her own restaurant, sues a builder who failed to finish building her first restaurant on time. She presents evidence of the profits made by similar restaurants that have been in business for some time. Is this good evidence of the damages she has suffered because of the delay? To what damages is she entitled?

Solutions

Expert Solution

Facts of the case :

Builder delayed to finish building due to which Alina was not able to open her first restaurant on time, where evidences of similar restaurants making profit were provided by her.

In this case, evidence of damages Alina suffered due to delay were not good due to following reason :

a. As profit she might have earned if restaurant was opened on time depends upon various factors such as quality of food, ambiance, efforts put forward to connect with customers, great staff etc.

b. Hence, instead of comparing with other restaurants cannot provide a good evidence which might cover the damages as even if restaurant was open on time there isn't any guarantee that her restaurant will earn similar profits.

She is entitled to liquidated damages and consequential damages where :

a. Liquidated damages are provided on the daily basis until the project is completed as it helps the plaintiff to cover the damages to some extent.

b. Consequential damages, if mentioned in the contract entitles the plaintiff for the loss profit, financial cost or reduced value of real estate which can negatively impact the client but such damages will only be provided if the damages were foreseeable.


Related Solutions

Christine is in the process of launching a restaurant. Christine has never owned her own restaurant...
Christine is in the process of launching a restaurant. Christine has never owned her own restaurant before, but she has worked for two of the best restaurants in town. Starting out as a waiter, Christine developed a special knack for the business and quickly worked her way up to the job of manager. Her 18 years of experience have given her a solid foundation for running her own restaurant. Christine prepared a business plan for her business. She asked two...
Merry is a chef. She runs her own restaurant business. During the year, Merry incurred the...
Merry is a chef. She runs her own restaurant business. During the year, Merry incurred the following expenses. Advise Merry as to whether the expenses below would be deductible for income tax purposes.       -       A.       B.       C.    salary costs to casual employees of $50,000       -       A.       B.       C.    salary costs of $2,000 to her sister (the amount is excessive, compared to the...
Suppose a young chef opened her own restaurant. To do so, she quit her old job...
Suppose a young chef opened her own restaurant. To do so, she quit her old job that paid her $45,500 per year, cashed in $33,000 in treasury bills that yielded 5.0% annual interest to buy equipment for the restaurant, and took over a store she owned that used to rent for $1000 per month. Her expenses during the first year totaled $50,000 for food, $35,000 for wait staff and part-time kitchen help, and $6000 for utilities (gas, electricity, and water)....
Alexis, a professional chef, is tired of the restaurant business and decides to open a toy...
Alexis, a professional chef, is tired of the restaurant business and decides to open a toy store. She and her CPA project income and expenses; perform site selection studies; and research product lines, advertising approaches, etc. Alexis locates Louie the Landlord, who plans to construct a small shopping center. Alexis looks at the plans and agrees to lease the corner location. The lease provides that Alexis is guaranteed occupancy by November 1 (at the start of the all-important holiday shopping...
Imagine yourself preparing to open a new restaurant. While you have never owned a restaurant yourself,...
Imagine yourself preparing to open a new restaurant. While you have never owned a restaurant yourself, you have over twenty years of experience in the industry, starting as a host(ess) and working up to a manager. You have approached many banks for loans, and have been turned down by all, since the restaurant business is very risky. What avenues might you pursue to gain the financing you need? For example, think outside of the box when it comes to considering...
Anthony is a chef who owns a small restaurant in Cleveland, Ohio as a sole proprietor....
Anthony is a chef who owns a small restaurant in Cleveland, Ohio as a sole proprietor. Because the business is struggling in the beginning, Anthony frequently puts money from his own personal account into the business account for the restaurant. After a while, business is picking up and he decides to expand by purchasing a food truck. In the beginning he is able to run the food truck during the day, and then open his restaurant just in the evening...
Question #2(a) Sansa is an entrepreneur and is looking to start her own business. Her sister,...
Question #2(a) Sansa is an entrepreneur and is looking to start her own business. Her sister, Arya, is interested in investing in the business with Sansa, but Sansa’s sister is concerned about being personally liable if the business does not do well. Sansa also would like to limit Arya’s personal liability. Which business form should Sansa and her sister consider if Sansa wants to retain sole control over the management of the company? (5 points) Question #2(b) Which business forms...
Law question: law of tort 1. Tom was an employee of the restaurant and Peter was...
Law question: law of tort 1. Tom was an employee of the restaurant and Peter was a customer. When serving the customers, Tom accidentally caused injury to Peter. Could Peter claim against the restaurant on his injury by reason of vicarious liability? As Peter was recovering from a previous injury, the accident resulted in Peter entirely losing the use of his leg. Could the claim by Peter be reduced due to his previous injury? The restaurant was in the shopping...
Lord who has been in business as a builder since 1 January 20X7 asks you to...
Lord who has been in business as a builder since 1 January 20X7 asks you to prepare his first year’s accounts. He has not kept proper records of his business transactions but is able to supply you with the following information: (1)       The cheques received for work done have been paid directly into the bank whilst cash receipts had been used for paying cash expenses. If insufficient cash was available, more would be drawn from the bank to meet wages...
Business Law question: Your business is being sued by Emily, a former employee, who claims that...
Business Law question: Your business is being sued by Emily, a former employee, who claims that she was sexually harassed by one of your other employees, Frank. Your business has a written employee policy manual that makes it clear that sexual harassment will not be tolerated at your workplace. It also designates one of your other female employees, Sarah, as the designated reporting person for reporting any incidents sexual harassment. Frank admits that one day, he flirted with Emily, and...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT