Question

In: Physics

This question is inspired by this question/answer pair: Is this formula for the energy of a...

This question is inspired by this question/answer pair: Is this formula for the energy of a configuration of 3 fluids physically reasonable?

Consider three immiscible fluids forming contact surfaces, where none of the three can make a lubrication layer for the other two (the surface energy between fluid 1 and fluid 2 is not decreased by putting a thin layer of fluid 3 inbetween them, and likewise for the other two permutations). In this case, if all the contact surface tensions are positive, you have a minimum energy when all the surfaces are flat.

But there is a separate line tension for the 3-fluid interface itself. Can this line tension be negative? If it is negative, the line would like to wriggle, but the surface tension will require that the wriggles straighten themselves out as quickly as possible, to make the surface energy least. In this case, the minimizing energy configuration seems to be a very rapidly wriggling curve which is only infinitesimally different at the atomic scale from straight line. This suggests that a negative line-tension always renormalizes to exactly zero line-tension at long wavelengths. Is this correct?

Are there experimental or computational 3-phase line interfaces with a negative line tension? Do they renormalize to a zero line tension limit? Does this mean that zero line tension is a common observation?

Solutions

Expert Solution

This is really a comment, but it got a bit long to put in the comment box.

Consider two immiscible fluids (of different densities) A and B forming the usual two phase system with a flat interface, and introduce a drop of a third immiscible fluid, C, at the interface so it forms a lens. The outer edge of the lens gives you the 3 fluid line, and at this line the three surface tensions must balance, otherwise the drop contact angle will change, and the line move, until the surface tensions balance.

Doesn't this mean the line tension is always zero? The only way the line tension could be non-zero is if the system cannot reach equilibrium i.e. the drop of C either rolls up or spreads infinitely, and in these cases there is no line of contact between the three fluids.

After some thought:

Look at the system above in another way. The way you'd calculate the line tension is to calculate the energy required to increase/decrease the line length. But you can't do this without changing the interfacial surface areas. So you need to make some perturbation and calculate the energy change, then calculate the change in the surface energies and subtract this. What you're left with is the contribution from the line tension.

But the way you calculate the conformation of the system is to minimise the surface energies, so once you've subtracted off the change in interfacial energy you're left with zero. So once again you reach the conclusion that the line tension must be zero.


Related Solutions

A high-energy photon in the vicinity of a nucleus can create an electron-positron pair by pair...
A high-energy photon in the vicinity of a nucleus can create an electron-positron pair by pair production: γ → e− + e+. (1) What minimum energy photon is required? _____________MeV (2) Why is the nucleus needed? a)Electrons can only exist inside the nucleus. b)Positrons can only exist inside the nucleus. c)The nucleus is required to absorb the energy so that conservation of energy is not violated. d)The nucleus is required to absorb the momentum so that conservation of momentum is...
please answer the question using Excel with formula please explain how the answer came 1. Many...
please answer the question using Excel with formula please explain how the answer came 1. Many drugs used to treat cancer are expensive. BusinessWeek reported on the cost per treatment of Herceptin, a drug used to treat breast cancer. Typical treatment costs (in dollars) for Herceptin are provided by a simple random sample of 10 patients. 5798​7446​5119​5376​5495​5237​4814​6578​3717​5920 a. Develop a point estimate of the mean cost per treatment with Herceptin. b. Develop a point estimate of the standard deviation of...
Use the savings plan formula to answer the following question. Your goal is to create a...
Use the savings plan formula to answer the following question. Your goal is to create a college fund for your child. Suppose you find a fund that offers an APR of 6%. How much should you deposit monthly to accumulate ​$83,000 in
Drive the formula of kinetic and potential energy of a pendulum.
Drive the formula of kinetic and potential energy of a pendulum.
Write a Formula for the ionic compound that forms from each pair of element Aluminum and...
Write a Formula for the ionic compound that forms from each pair of element Aluminum and oxygen Beryllium and iodine Calcium and sulfur Calcium and iodine
Write the formula for the ionic compound formed from each pair of elements. a. rubidium and...
Write the formula for the ionic compound formed from each pair of elements. a. rubidium and iodine b. calcium and oxygen
Formaldehyde has the formula CH2O. Draw the Lewis structure and answer the following question. The carbon...
Formaldehyde has the formula CH2O. Draw the Lewis structure and answer the following question. The carbon atom has ____ hybridization and the oxygen atom has ____ hybridization. . sp2; sp B. sp2; sp3d C. sp2; sp3 D. sp2; sp2 E. sp3; sp2
(Try to work this question WITHOUT using Excel, get answer by using the formula and show...
(Try to work this question WITHOUT using Excel, get answer by using the formula and show the calculations in detail) Question (Retirement planning) You have just graduated Hofstra University at age 22. You hard work has paid off as you already have a job as an investment banker at Goldman Sachs waiting for you. You plan to work continuously until age 65 and retire exactly on that day. You expect to live until exactly 90 and enjoy your golden years...
Explain conservation of mechanical energy (including formula) in terms of potential and kinetic energy using an...
Explain conservation of mechanical energy (including formula) in terms of potential and kinetic energy using an example in your sport
Distance formula based question
Find the distance between the following pair of points(2,5) , (3,2)
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT