Question

In: Accounting

what is criticisms of ROI and why the residual income may be a better indicator than...

what is criticisms of ROI and why the residual income may be a better indicator than the ROI?

Solutions

Expert Solution

Although ROI is widely used in evaluating performance, it is not a perfect tool. it is subject to following criticisims :

  1. Just telling managers ti increase ROI is not enough. managers may not now how to increase ROI , they may increase ROI in a way that is inconsistent with the company's strategy or they may take steps that increase ROI in a short run but harm company in long run.
  2. A manager who takes over a business segment typically inherent many committed costs over which the manager has no control. These committed costs may be relevant in assessing the performance of the business segment as an investment but make it difficult to fairly assess the performance of the manager relative to other manager,
  3. A manager who is evaluated based on ROI may reject investment opportunities that are profitable for the company but that would have a negative impact on manager's performance evaluation.
  4. The level of investment or capital employed can be difficult to measure and this can distort inter-firm comparisons.

RESIDUAL INCOME IS A BETTER INDICATOR THAN ROI :

It is another measure of performance evaluation based on investment in assets. It compares the profit actually earned to the minimum level of profit required for the business. It is profit earned less interest o minimum return on the capital that has been employed to generate the profit. It is considered a better method because it is an absolute measure as it measures in terms of money rather than in terms of percentage. It is ideal for comparisons across corporate divisions for companies of similar size and in similar sector.


Related Solutions

What are the strengths and weaknesses of using Residual Income (RI), Return on Investment (ROI), or...
What are the strengths and weaknesses of using Residual Income (RI), Return on Investment (ROI), or Economic Value Added (EVA®) as methods to evaluate management performance? Which method would you like to be assessed by, if you were a manager? Would it make a difference if you were in charge of a department, plant, or major division? Why or why not? Support you answer with examples.
When do you think ROI is a more useful performance measure than residual income? How would...
When do you think ROI is a more useful performance measure than residual income? How would you describe a balanced score card and how it helps an organization meet its goals?
what is Genuine Progres Index, and is it a better indicator than GDP/GNP when it comes...
what is Genuine Progres Index, and is it a better indicator than GDP/GNP when it comes to economic health.
A positive evaluation of a manager would include Residual Income of zero and an ROI greater...
A positive evaluation of a manager would include Residual Income of zero and an ROI greater than the minimum requirement 1) True. 2) False. Question 4 Residual income of $10,000 indicates the manager is earning above the minimum requirement but residual income of zero ($0) indicates the manager is earning below the minimum requirement. 1) True. 2) False. Residual income should not be used to evaluate a profit center. 1) True. 2) False. The World Peace Co. has three divisions:...
ROI and Residual Income: Impact of a New Investment The Mustang Division of Detroit Motors had...
ROI and Residual Income: Impact of a New Investment The Mustang Division of Detroit Motors had an operating income of $900,000 and net assets of $4,000,000. Detroit Motors has a target rate of return of 16 percent. (a) Compute the return on investment. (Round your answer to three decimal places.) Answer (b) Compute the residual income. $Answer (c) The Mustang Division has an opportunity to increase operating income by $250,000 with an $750,000 investment in assets. 1. Compute the Mustang...
What is the Residual Income?
Jarren Cough drops operates two divisions. The following information pertains to each division for year 1.   Required   Compute each division’s residual income. Which division increased the company’s profitability more?
What is the residual Income?
Zachary Cough Drops operates two divisions. The following information pertains to each division for Year 1.    Division A   Division B Sales $ 220,000     $ 88,000   Operating income $ 16,500     $ 9,000   Average operating assets $ 60,000     $ 45,000   Company's desired rate of return   11 %     11 % Required     Compute each division’s residual income. Which division increased the company’s profitability more?  
Residual income, ROI, and EVA The following selected data pertain to Brannard Company's Construction Division for...
Residual income, ROI, and EVA The following selected data pertain to Brannard Company's Construction Division for last year. Sales $2,380,000 Variable costs $1,428,000 Traceable fixed costs $238,000 Average invested capital (assets) $3,570,000 Current liabilities $238,000 Required rate of return 15% Marginal tax rate 36% Weighted average cost of capital 12% 1. Calculate the residual income. $______ 2. Calculate the return on investment. ______% 3. Calculate the economic value added. $______
Residual income, ROI, and EVA The following selected data pertain to Brannard Company's Construction Division for...
Residual income, ROI, and EVA The following selected data pertain to Brannard Company's Construction Division for last year. Sales $2,380,000 Variable costs $1,428,000 Traceable fixed costs $238,000 Average invested capital (assets) $3,570,000 Current liabilities $238,000 Required rate of return 15% Marginal tax rate 36% Weighted average cost of capital 12% QN: 1. Calculate the residual income. $______ 2. Calculate the return on investment. ______% 3. Calculate the economic value added. $______
For the first company division listed, insert formula commands to calculate ROI and Residual income (assume...
For the first company division listed, insert formula commands to calculate ROI and Residual income (assume the company has a 25% target rate of return). To insert formulas, highlight the cell where you want to place the answer. (Please Provide Excel Formula used) Use the “Copy” and “Paste” commands to copy the same formulas into the appropriate cell for each division. Use the “%” on the “Number” section of the menu bar to format the ROI as a percentage. Format...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT