Question

In: Finance

You are a small business owner considering two alternatives for your phone system. Plan A Plan...

You are a small business owner considering two alternatives for your phone system.

	Plan A	Plan B
Initial cost ($)	50,000	120,000
Annual maintenance cost ($)	9,000	6,000
Salvage value ($)	10,000	20,000
Life	20 years	40 years

The discount rate is 8%. Which alternative would you pick?

Plan A or Plan B

Expert Solution

Calculation of EAC of Plan A

n = 20 years

r = discount rate = 8%

P = annual maintenance cost = -$9,000

NPV of the Plan A = [P * [1 - (1+r)^-n] / r] + [Salvage Value / (1+r)^n] - Initial Cost

= [-$9,000 * [1 - (1+8%)^-20] / 8%] + [$10,000 / (1+8%)^20] - $50,000

= [-$9,000 * 0.785451793 / 0.08] + [$10,000 /4.66095714 ] - $50,000

= -$88,363.3268 + $2,145.48208 - $50,000

= -$136,217.845

EAC of Plan A = [r*NPV] / [1 - (1+r)^-n]

= [8% * -$136,217.845] / [1 - (1+8%)^-20]

= -$10,879.4276 / 0.785451793

= -$13,851.1716

= -$13,851.17

Calculation of EAC of Plan B

n = 40 years

r = discount rate = 8%

P = annual maintenance cost = -$6,000

NPV of the Plan B = [P * [1 - (1+r)^-n] / r] + [Salvage Value / (1+r)^n] - Initial Cost

= [-$6,000 * [1 - (1+8%)^-40] / 8%] + [$20,000 / (1+8%)^40] - $120,000

= [-$6,000 * 0.953969067/ 0.08] + [$20,000 /21.7245215] - $120,000

= -$71,547.68 + $920.618666 - $120,000

= -$191,527.061

EAC of Plan B = [r*NPV] / [1 - (1+r)^-n]

= [8% * -$191,527.061] / [1 - (1+8%)^-40]

= -$15,322.1649 / 0.953969067

= -$16,061.4903

= -$16,061.49

EAC of Plan B is higher than Plan A hence it is better to choose Plan A

jeff jeffy answered 2 years ago

Exercise: Preparing Your Business Plan You are considering the possibility of operating a small business or...

Exercise: Preparing Your Business Plan You are considering the possibility of operating a small business or practice in some activity related to health care, as either a provider or as a service intended to support various provider organizations in their care-delivery activities. First, describe the kind of entity you would be establishing by stating the service or services you propose to deliver and the kinds of clients or customers you would be serving. Next, write a paragraph offering compelling reasons...

Develop a Marketing Plan Choose a relatively small business you perceive its owner as entrepreneur existed...

Develop a Marketing Plan Choose a relatively small business you perceive its owner as entrepreneur existed in Saudi Arabia, or one of the middle-east countries, you can use your own if you have private business. Develop the company`s Marketing Plan with the following details; Marketing Plan a. Market Research- Why? b. Market Research- How? Primary or Secondary Data? c. In your marketing plan, be as specific as possible; give statistics, numbers, and sources. The marketing plan will be the basis,...

Assume that you are a consultant to a small business. The owner of the business does...

Assume that you are a consultant to a small business. The owner of the business does not have an accounting background and has turned to you for assistance.The owner believes that one or more employees may be stealing inventory from the business. Write a memorandum to the business owner in which you identify the type of business and answer the following questions: Identify two (2) signs that an employee might be stealing from the business that detail what should the...

Do you support trade if you are a small local business owner? Share your thoughts and...

Do you support trade if you are a small local business owner? Share your thoughts and tell us your interested industry, and how free trade and different trade policies such as tariffs and duties will affect your business?

If you were a small business owner would you want to most of your costs fixed...

If you were a small business owner would you want to most of your costs fixed or variable?

Assume you are the owner of a small apparel manufacturer with approximately fifty employees. Your business...

Assume you are the owner of a small apparel manufacturer with approximately fifty employees. Your business is located in a blighted area of town where the jobs you provide are important, but the insurance costs of doing business there are significant, too. Recently, fire and theft coverage has escalated in cost, but it is essential to protect your premises and inventory, and local ordinances require that you purchase it. You have customarily provided health coverage for your employees and their...

Pensions If you were a business owner, what type of plan would you offer your workers?...

Pensions If you were a business owner, what type of plan would you offer your workers? Why this type?

If you were a small business owner, how would your inability to collect your receivable timely...

If you were a small business owner, how would your inability to collect your receivable timely affect your business operations?

Assume you are a small business owner and operate within your own home. You must determine...

Assume you are a small business owner and operate within your own home. You must determine which accounting method and accounting period to use. What would you choose? Explain your reasoning. Your reflection should be at least 150 words.

You are a business owner and your business is growing but you believe it is not...

You are a business owner and your business is growing but you believe it is not growing fast enough and you need an infusion of capital to help speed up the growth. You have a friend who is willing to loan you the capital needed but he wants to make sure that you are able to pay the loan back (plus interest) and he needs some proof that you can deliver. What financial statements are you likely to furnish to...