Question

In: Economics

Which strategy is better for ensuring sustainability: Government Regulation or Market Self-Regulation? Give example.

Which strategy is better for ensuring sustainability: Government Regulation or Market Self-Regulation? Give example.

Solutions

Expert Solution

in achieving sustainability—lock-in or path dependency caused by the failure of firms to envision, design, and implement policies that would simultaneously achieve social, environmental, and economic goals. Policy interventions are needed to increase not only capacity, but also willingness, opportunity, and motivation on the part of incumbents and new entrants to change the present industrial state into a more sustainable one. Structural interventions at all levels of governance are needed to foster breakthrough technological innovations. These structural interventions should integrate environmental, health, and safety decision-making with decision-making on employment and trade policies. Other interventions include specific legal and policy instruments that will encourage and even force such innovations in a manner that will achieve environmental, economic, and social objectives in a mutually reinforcing way.

Who is likely to win and who is likely to lose from an industrial transformation is also a question that should be considered. Persons, firms, and governments who benefit from maintaining the status quo or continuing its trends can well drive us deeper into unsustainability. They create a major source of lock-in and path dependence—entrenched economic and political interests that gain from the present system and advancement of its current trends through the exercise of monopoly power, financial privilege and control, advertising, and regulatory and political capture, even though the citizens as a whole in a nation may not benefit, or may even be harmed. Further, they stand in the way of different actors who may provide better pathways. To address these concerns requires a different focus of (mostly) legal interventions than those directed towards enhancing the capacity to change through a deepening and integration of interventions that open up the problem space. Policies are needed to ‘open up the participatory and political space.’ These include using the power of legal compulsion through law and legal institutions, antitrust law, legal changes in the chartering of corporations, the limiting of unjustified profiteering, the restraint of advertising, the cessation of rewarding excessive consumption of both materials and energy, subsidizing the wrong kind of production and provision of services, countering and punishing financial corruption and fraud, and fair employment and wage policies. Example - goverment want to control the inflation or controlling inflation is a necessary need of the economy . So in such case government intervention is necessary , we cannot wait for market self regulations .

Such interventions ‘open up the participatory and political space’ and are different from other interventions opening up the problem space for envisioning, designing, and implementing technological innovations that achieve social, environmental, and economic goals in mutually reinforcing ways—but they can be of equal importance. Finally, it should be clear that we are advocating stronger, not bigger government. Integrating governmental policies and initiatives could very well result in smaller government than one that operates in a fragmented way. Hence Government regulations are better than market self regulations .


Related Solutions

Discuss the role of government in funding and regulation as it relates to ensuring delivery of...
Discuss the role of government in funding and regulation as it relates to ensuring delivery of quality health care: How successful have its efforts been? What effect have government efforts had on the private health care industry (e.g., care facilities, insurance companies, and drug companies)?
Give an example of a population of clients for which submaximal testing is a better choice...
Give an example of a population of clients for which submaximal testing is a better choice for evaluating cardiorespiratory fitness than is maximal testing.
2 Give an example of a healthcare circumstance in which both public and private regulation are...
2 Give an example of a healthcare circumstance in which both public and private regulation are present. Which serves the consumers better and why? 3 Assuming you are the manager of a company, how could you use behavioral economics to increase the number of insured employees in your firm?
Which method of emotional self-regulation is most closely associated with Freud’s theories? Give three examples of...
Which method of emotional self-regulation is most closely associated with Freud’s theories? Give three examples of such coping behaviors.
Explain the concept of market failure. Give an example of a government policy or action to...
Explain the concept of market failure. Give an example of a government policy or action to deal with market failure
Give a unique (realistic or fictional) example of the government interfering in a market to institute...
Give a unique (realistic or fictional) example of the government interfering in a market to institute a price control (price ceiling or price floor). Explain the government's goal with implementing the price control. Explain who is likely to benefit and who is likely to lose, including reference to deadweight loss. What suggestion would you make instead of a price control that will help meet the government's goal with less negative impact (explain the economic impact this has in the market)?
How is regulation often imperialistic? Give a specific example. In what way is measuring market concentration...
How is regulation often imperialistic? Give a specific example. In what way is measuring market concentration of the airline industry different from measuring market concentration in other industries? Use the economic theories of regulation from chapter 10 to explain the observed patterns of deregulation in the U.S. transportation sector. How does vertical unbundling allow for deregulation of the electricity industry? What is the rationale for regulating the financial sector? What is the cost associated with regulation?
How is regulation often imperialistic? Give a specific example.
How is regulation often imperialistic? Give a specific example.
Which of the following is most likely a strategy for self-improvement?
Which of the following is most likely a strategy for self-improvement?comparing your performance to otherssetting specific goals for yourselffocusing on your obstaclesclarifying your mistakesdemanding help from others
What happens in the absence of control? Give an example of a standard for sustainability. What...
What happens in the absence of control? Give an example of a standard for sustainability. What impact would achieving Six Sigma quality have on a company’s costs? If one activity costs the most, how would you decide if this is a case of overspending? You manage the tech support department for your company. How might market controls affect your costs? Would you expect more clan control with standardized jobs or creative positions?
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT