Question

In: Math

Why can't correlations tell us anything about cause and effect?  Going further, what kind of an...

Why can't correlations tell us anything about cause and effect?  Going further, what kind of an experimental design would you need to explain cause and effect?  Provide an example to illustrate your point.

Solutions

Expert Solution

Why can't correlations tell us anything about cause and effect?  

Two or more variables considered to be related, in a statistical context, if their values change so that as the value of one variable increases or decreases so does the value of the other variable (although it may be in the opposite direction).

For example, for the two variables "hours worked" and "income earned" there is a relationship between the two if the increase in hours worked is associated with an increase in income earned. If we consider the two variables "price" and "purchasing power", as the price of goods increases a person's ability to buy these goods decreases (assuming a constant income).


Correlation is a statistical measure (expressed as a number) that describes the size and direction of a relationship between two or more variables. A correlation between variables, however, does not automatically mean that the change in one variable is the cause of the change in the values of the other variable.


Causation indicates that one event is the result of the occurrence of the other event; i.e. there is a causal relationship between the two events. This is also referred to as cause and effect.


Theoretically, the difference between the two types of relationships are easy to identify — an action or occurrence can cause another (e.g. smoking causes an increase in the risk of developing lung cancer), or it can correlate with another (e.g. smoking is correlated with alcoholism, but it does not cause alcoholism). In practice, however, it remains difficult to clearly establish cause and effect, compared with establishing correlation.

what kind of an experimental design would you need to explain cause and effect? Provide an example to illustrate your point.

Both cross-sectional and longitudinal research studies are observational. They are both conducted without any interference to the study participants. Cross-sectional research is conducted at a single point in time while a longitudinal study can be conducted over many years.

For example, let’s say researchers wanted to find out if older adults who gardened had lower blood pressure than older adults who did not garden. In a cross-sectional study, the researchers might select 100 people from different backgrounds, ask them about their gardening habits and measure their blood pressure. The study would be conducted at approximately the same period of time (say, over a week). In a longitudinal study, the questions and measurements would be the same. But the researchers would follow the participants over time. They may record the answers and measurements every year.

One major advantage of longitudinal research is that over time, researchers are more able to provide a cause-and-effect relationship. With the blood pressure example above, cross-sectional research wouldn’t give researchers information about what blood pressure readings were before the study. For example, participants may have had lower blood pressure before gardening. Longitudinal research can detect changes over time, both at the group and at the individual level.


Related Solutions

Explain what the Doppler effect is and what it can tell us about the motion of...
Explain what the Doppler effect is and what it can tell us about the motion of distant objects.
Someone else - what kind of account is "allowance for doubtful accounts". 1. Tell us about...
Someone else - what kind of account is "allowance for doubtful accounts". 1. Tell us about aging of receivables. Why would we age them? 2. What method are we using when we estimate bad debts? 3. what are the two methods of estimating bad debts? Which is easier for you to remember and why? 4. If you were focusing on your income statement (matching expenses to revenues), which method of estimating would you use?
Let's begin by talking about plant assets. Can you tell us what kind of plant assets...
Let's begin by talking about plant assets. Can you tell us what kind of plant assets are used in your company or place of business? Do you have an estimate of the amount invested in those plant assets?
enterprenuership in actions...tell us about us.
enterprenuership in actions...tell us about us.
Why is the phenomenon of Learned Flavor Aversions important? What does it tell us about learning,...
Why is the phenomenon of Learned Flavor Aversions important? What does it tell us about learning, in general?
1. The correlations between +/-, PTS, AST, TOV. What does this tell you about how each...
1. The correlations between +/-, PTS, AST, TOV. What does this tell you about how each of the variables are related? Explain. Variable +/- Points AST TOV +/- 1 Pts 0.446 1 AST 0.354 0.608 1 TOV -0.081 -0.183 -0.077 1 2. Home/Away data is made up of only two numerical results which 1s and 0s. Would it be appropriate to also include Home/Away in correlation? Explain
1. What, if anything, does each of the following quotations tell you about the demand elasticity?...
1. What, if anything, does each of the following quotations tell you about the demand elasticity? Explain. a. "I drink two cups of coffee every morning regardless of the price." b. "Attendance at the ball park went down when they increased the ticket price, but in spite of the decreased attendance, more money was taken in.” c. "When the newspaper raised its price, the number of newspapers sold dropped by 20%. d. My budget is $10 a week for cigarettes....
what do granulation and supergranulation tell us about the sun
what do granulation and supergranulation tell us about the sun
What does the empirical rule tell us about the spread of normalpopulations?
What does the empirical rule tell us about the spread of normal populations?
What does a Southwell plot tell us about column imperfections?
What does a Southwell plot tell us about column imperfections?
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT