Question

In: Economics

In order to establish a claim for negligence, the plaintiff must prove that: Multiple Choice The...

In order to establish a claim for negligence, the plaintiff must prove that:

Multiple Choice

  • The defendant was either comparatively or contributorily negligent.

  • The plaintiff was contributorily negligent.

  • The plaintiff sustained nominal damages.

  • The plaintiff acted as a reasonable person under the situation.

Solutions

Expert Solution

The element that must be proved is causation. The plaintiff must be able to show that the negligent actions of the defendant directly caused the injuries to the plaintiff. The defendant is not necessarily responsible for the injuries of the defendant just because they were in breach of duty. For example, suppose a woman receives an operation and, prior to that operation, a nurse fails to scrub up properly. During the surgery, a sponge is left inside the woman and she develops an infection. In this case, both the surgeon and the nurse were in breach of duty, but the injuries are not due to the nurse’s breach of duty. Causation can only be shown in the case of the surgeon’s breach of duty, therefore, even though the nurse did not meet minimal standards of behavior, she did not cause the injuries to occur and cannot be held negligent in this case.Finally, the plaintiff must be able to prove damages. Most times, the plaintiff has a stack of medical bills and records that clearly indicate that they were injured. It is important, however, that the physician notes the nature of the injury. A note saying you have a chronic back condition is going to carry far less weight than one saying you have a spinal hernia due to damage sustained in a car accident.

Hence ( B ) part is a correct answer


Related Solutions

26.a. What must a plaintiff prove to succeed in a defendant's negligence claim? A) In order...
26.a. What must a plaintiff prove to succeed in a defendant's negligence claim? A) In order to succeed in an action based on the negligence of the defendant, the plaintiff must prove the following: 1. The defendant has failed in his obligation of confidentiality; 2. The conduct of the defendant has caused damage and / or economic loss; 3. There is a causal link between the damage suffered and the fault of the defendant. B) To succeed in a defendant's...
Describe the kinds of evidence that a plaintiff can present in order to establish a negligent...
Describe the kinds of evidence that a plaintiff can present in order to establish a negligent act. What defenses can a defendant present in order to refute a plaintiff's evidence? How do statutes of limitations protect professional nurse-defendants? Do they also protect the injured parties? What can staff nurses do to protect patients from quasi-intentional torts? Does this differ from the nurse manager's role in preventing quasi-intentional torts?
Explain what a plaintiff needs to establish in order to be able to sue a defendant...
Explain what a plaintiff needs to establish in order to be able to sue a defendant for a breach of contract and what types of remedies are generally available to a plaintiff for breach of contract. Please illustrate your answer with applicable case law examples. (country of law: Australia)
24) In a ciriminal case, the plaintiff must prove the case by the preponderance of the...
24) In a ciriminal case, the plaintiff must prove the case by the preponderance of the evidence True False 25) The President of the United States a. creates federal common law b. oversees administrative agencies c. determines the constitutionality of statutes d. passes statutes 27) The President of the United States a. creates federal common law b. oversees administrative agencies c. determines the constitutionality of statutes d. passes statutes 28) Punitive damages are intended to: a. compensate the plaintiff for...
Which of the following must be established by a plaintiff in a discrimination case, in order...
Which of the following must be established by a plaintiff in a discrimination case, in order to set forth a "prima facie" case? The plaintiff must establish that he or she: (1) belongs to a protected class; (2) was qualified for the job; and (3) was subjected to an adverse employment action; and (4) the employer gave better treatment to a similarly-situated person outside the plaintiff’s protected class. Group of answer choices -That the plaintiff belongs to a protected class....
In a civil case in Canada, such a tort claim, what must the Plaintiff do? Question...
In a civil case in Canada, such a tort claim, what must the Plaintiff do? Question 8 options: Introduce evidence which proves his/her case beyond a reasonable doubt. Introduce evidence which proves his/her case on a balance of probabilities. Introduce evidence which proves his/her case is just as likely to be the true version of events as the Defendant's. Introduce evidence which proves his/her case is completely correct.
If the plaintiff in a defamation suit is a public figure, he must prove that the defendant acted with _________
1. Fill in the blanks.If the plaintiff in a defamation suit is a public figure, he must prove that the defendant acted with _________ __________.2.Fill in the blanks.If an event would not have occurred except for the defendant’s negligence, there is________ ___________ ; plaintiff must also prove that it was foreseeable that the plaintiff might be injured to satisfy the additional requirement of __________.3.Fill in the blanks.A difference between a tort claim and a claim for breach of contract is...
6. What must a taxpayer prove to establish that an understatement of income tax should not...
6. What must a taxpayer prove to establish that an understatement of income tax should not be subject to the I.R.C. 6662 penalty because of the following? a. Reduction for substantial authority for return position. b. Reduction for disclosure in return.
5. What must a taxpayer prove to establish the defense of shift of responsibility for purposes...
5. What must a taxpayer prove to establish the defense of shift of responsibility for purposes of I.R.C. $6662?
For a plaintiff to recover in a breach of contract case, the plaintiff must demonstrate that...
For a plaintiff to recover in a breach of contract case, the plaintiff must demonstrate that he used reasonable efforts to minimize the damage resulting from the breach of contract by the defendant. True or False?
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT