Question

In: Chemistry

What are the similarities between the Rutherford-Bohr atom and the modern quantum mechanical model? What are...

What are the similarities between the Rutherford-Bohr atom and the modern quantum mechanical model? What are the differences? Why is the Rutherford-Bohr model still useful? In what situations would you use one model over the other? Why?

Solutions

Expert Solution

Similarities: in both Bohr's model and Quantum mechanical model assign specific energies to electron and electrons are at different distances from the nucleus.

Differences: in Bohr's model, electrons are treated as particles & electrons are revolving aronud the nucleus in certain selected orbits, which are associated with a definite energy and hence it is one dimensional.

in Quantum mechanical model, electrons are mathematically treated as waves and hence it is three dimensional.


Related Solutions

What was the fundamental idea in the Bohr model that is still true in the quantum mechanical model?
The Bohr model was important, even though it ultimately didn't work out for multi-electron atoms. What was the fundamental idea in the Bohr model that is still true in the quantum mechanical model? 
Describe the Bohr model and describe the quantum-mechanical model of the electron. What is the advantage...
Describe the Bohr model and describe the quantum-mechanical model of the electron. What is the advantage of each model and what is the major difference between the two models?
Describe the quantum mechanical model of the atom. Why is this model more accurate than the...
Describe the quantum mechanical model of the atom. Why is this model more accurate than the classical model? Please Type Answer and No Plagiarism!
3. Prior to quantum mechanics the Bohr Model viewed the atom as having electrons traveling in...
3. Prior to quantum mechanics the Bohr Model viewed the atom as having electrons traveling in circular orbits (shells) about the positively charged nucleus. This model gives a reasonable estimate of the dipole moment of the hydrogen atom if one assumes the radius of the electron orbit about the nucleus is 5.3 x 10-11 m. Using the Bohr Model (a) what is the dipole moment of the hydrogen atom? Now place the hydrogen atom in a magnetic field, B, with...
Describe the Bohr model of the hydrogen atom, and explain how Planck's quantum theory contributed to...
Describe the Bohr model of the hydrogen atom, and explain how Planck's quantum theory contributed to it
what are the strengths and weaknesses of the Bohr model of the atom?
what are the strengths and weaknesses of the Bohr model of the atom?
Bohr theory of the atom: In the hydrogenic Bohr orbit of quantum number n compute the...
Bohr theory of the atom: In the hydrogenic Bohr orbit of quantum number n compute the ratio of the circumference of the orbit to the wavelength of the electron. Provide an interpretation of this result in terms of the concepts of de Broglie. Treating the Bohr orbit as a circulating electrical current, compute the magnetic moment of the electron in a Bohr orbit of quantum number n (Hint: use Ampere’s law). What is the ratio between the magnetic moment and...
General Chem 1 Compare the current quantum mechanical model of the atom to the classical (...
General Chem 1 Compare the current quantum mechanical model of the atom to the classical ( pre-1913 ) model. Identify similarities and at least three differences. Reference to historical development leading to changes may be incorporated.
what is the lowest energy orbital in the quantum mechanical model
what is the lowest energy orbital in the quantum mechanical model
What is the diameter of the hydrogen atom as calculated by the Bohr model? What does...
What is the diameter of the hydrogen atom as calculated by the Bohr model? What does this mean about the Bohr model? What is the new picture?
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT