In: Statistics and Probability
In a series of journal articles, investigator A reported her data, which are approximately normally distributed, in terms of a mean plus or minus two standard deviations, while investigator B reported his data in terms of a mean plus or minus two standard errors of the mean. The difference between the two methods is
investigator A is estimating the extreme percentiles, whereas
investigator |
||
investigator A is estimating the range that she thinks contains 95% of the means, whereas investigator B is estimating the range that he thinks contains 95% of the medians |
||
investigator A is estimating the range that she thinks contains about 95% of her data values, whereas investigator B is estimating the range that he thinks (with 95% confidence) contains the true mean being estimated |
||
investigators A and B are really estimating the same range, but are just using different systems of reporting |
||
none of the above |
Ans :
investigator A is estimating the range that she thinks contains about 95% of her data values, whereas investigator B is estimating the range that he thinks (with 95% confidence) contains the true mean being estimated
Explanation for investigator A part of the question
investigator A reported her data, which are approximately normally distributed, in terms of a mean plus or minus two standard deviations
by 68-95-99 rule of normal distribution
68% of the data is within 1 standard deviation of the mean , 95% of the data is within 2 standard deviations of the mean and 99.7% of the data is within 3 standard deviations of the mean.
so therefore, Investigator A thinks 95% of the data is within 2 standard deviations of the mean i.e
investigator A is estimating the range that she thinks contains about 95% of her data values,
investigator B reported his data in terms of a mean plus or minus two standard errors of the mean
95% Confidence interval formula
sample mean Z0.025 Standard error.
Z0.025 = 1.96 2
Therefore, mean plus or minus two standard errors of the mean represents the 95% confidence interval estimate for the true mean.
i.e
investigator B is estimating the range that he thinks (with 95% confidence) contains the true mean being estimated