In: Operations Management
Team 3 answer the following questions
1-What are 4 key things you learned about the topic from reading their paper?
2-How does the topic relate to you and your current or past job?
3-Critique the paper in terms of the organization and quality.
Organizational Culture and its Effect on the Corporate
Environment
An
organization is a commercial or non-commercial place of business
created for a particular purpose, where individuals from many
different backgrounds, both educational and personal, come together
to achieve a common goal. This shared goal is based on
organizational or management objectives, but the primary goal of
most organizations is long term success by achieving productivity,
profitably, and financial benchmarks set forth by company
executives and shareholders. The organizational culture of the
workplace encompasses the beliefs, values and guiding principles
that help decide the way employees, and other stakeholders interact
with one another, while pursuing a path towards long term success
(Brown, 2011). Although company cultures are differentiated based
on classification and function, every organization has a culture.
There are many classifications of corporate culture from normative,
to pragmatic, to club cultures, however there are two main
categories of organizational culture which these classifications
fall under; strong organizational culture and weak organizational
culture.
A strong organizational culture pursues corporate goals by ensuring
that all employees conduct themselves in an ethical and
professional manner to reach corporate benchmarks by promoting a
shared set of values, beliefs, and principles described in the
organization’s mission, vision, and values statements. A weak
organizational culture does not. The organization’s culture is
shaped by the members of the organization, and is subject to
constant change based on who remains within the organization over
time. In society today, corporate culture is said to be influenced
by the motivation of the employees and stakeholders. As we examine
in depth what exactly makes up a strong versus weak organizational
culture, we can better prepare a strategic plan for an organization
that is preparing for change, as well as determine the best
possible solutions for an organization that is receiving
resistance, and other challenges to change by its employees.
Characteristics of Strong Organizational Culture
A myriad of traits and norms encompass strong culture, and a strong
culture is something that is built over time. According to the
Harvard Business Review (2017), “culture is among the primary
levers at top leaders’ disposal in their never-ending quest to
maintain organizational viability and effectiveness.” In order to
have a strong organizational culture, a company should have these
four characteristics: a strong purpose, a sense of enjoyment, a
plan for learning, and evaluation of results.
When
discussing an organization’s culture, one of the most important
characteristics is a strong purpose. As stated by the Harvard
Business Review (2017), “work environments with a strong purpose
are tolerant, compassionate places where people try to do good for
the long-term future of the world. Employees are united by a focus
on sustainability and global communities; leaders emphasize shared
ideals and contributing to a greater cause.” When an organization
has a clear and strong purpose, employees are attracted and
motivated to work there, and are also easier to retain. Working for
an organization with a strong purpose would be fulfilling that need
of belonging and importance that most employees seem to be striving
for today in the workplace.
Another characteristic that makes up a strong organizational
culture is enjoyment. A majority of the working class may have been
working the same job for many years, and have become almost
habitual in their everyday tasks. A company that can bring
enjoyment to the workplace is taking one of the necessary steps to
build a strong organizational culture. The Harvard Business Review
(2017) stated, “enjoyment is expressed through fun and excitement.
Employees are united by playfulness and stimulation; leaders should
emphasize spontaneity and a sense of humor.” Businesses should
strive to provide excitement within the workplace, whether its
during work hours or after hours.
Another important characteristic is learning
or professional development. The Harvard Business Review (2017)
wrote that, “work environments are inventive and open-minded places
where people spark new ideas and explore alternatives.” When it
comes to learning and training employees, one particular
organization stands out; Keller Williams Realty. Training Magazine
had named Keller Williams Realty a top five training organization
for five consecutive years across all industries because of their
incredible employee development programs called MAPS (McLaughlin,
2014). Today, people are always looking to grow both personally and
professionally, so an organization that invests in the time,
training and personal development of its employees is investing in
its future.
Lastly, a strong organizational culture is likely to produce
results. Per the Harvard Business Review (2017), “results are
characterized by achievement and winning. Work environments are
outcome-oriented and merit-based places where people aspire to
achieve top performance.” For example, I can reflect on a time with
a past employer where I found no strong, meaningful purpose in the
work I was performing. The organization also lacked a sense of
excitement, and there were no employee development programs or
promise of advancement. There was no desire from my employer to
keep pushing the boundaries for better results, and organizational
success. Maybe one day that will change for my former employer, but
for organizations that have all four characteristics; purpose,
excitement, learning and results, a strong organizational culture
is attainable.
Characteristics of Weak Organizational Culture
As stated by the Journal of Applied Psychology (2012),
organizational culture is not a steady culture, but it is
constantly evolving. It is important to stay up to date on current
research as to what constitutes a strong or weak organizational
culture, and how to maintain a strong culture within a company.
Members of a weak organizational culture may have vastly different
visions, pulling the organization in their own or opposite
directions. A research study was published in the Journal of
Applied Psychology (2012), which attempted to find a correlation
between organizational culture and performance. The study used a
sample of 138 different organizational teams within a Fortune 500
company. The study showed that there was a strong, positive
correlation between a high-level performance and a strong cultural
organization, and a negative correlation between low-level
performance and a weak organizational culture.
According to a journal article within the Global Business Review
(2017), “the more the organizational members agree on, widely share
and remain committed to a set of common values and practices, the
stronger the culture tends to be.” Therefore, a weak organizational
culture is when members do not share common values. A great example
of a weak organizational culture would be the summer camp I once
worked for. The camp did attempt to maintain a shared vision
throughout all its members, but did lack some elements of a strong
organizational culture. My camp attempted to attract international
diversity within their employees, and I had worked with
co-counselors from vastly different backgrounds. All of us had
different values, attitudes, and beliefs, which contributed to a
lack of similar vision of what an effective summer camp counselor
should be. Therefore, no matter how much training was given to each
of the counselors during orientation week, based on my
observations, we were all fundamentally different in our styles of
interacting and disciplining the children.
Impact of Change on Weak Organizational Culture
A company, no matter its market share or competitive advantage,
will always run the risk of falling behind the competition if it
does not maintain a strong or effective company culture. According
to the course content, many outside factors, such as the general
health of the economy or societal strains, may have an impact on an
organization’s culture. Problems in organizations are often shaped
by a host of factors including, critically, those internal to
organizations (Howard-Grenville, 2007.)
Employees need to feel comfortable with the idea of organizational
change in the workplace in order for executives to not be faced
with resistance, or at the very least, face little resistance. The
reason for resistance is that an organization’s employees are
usually invested in the current policies and procedures that their
organization currently operates under. If something were to change
later on, whether suddenly or over time, they would have to adjust,
which humans have a natural aversion to. According to the course
lectures, the following are some common reasons for resistance to
change, which may cause an organization’s culture to be weakened:
fear of the unknown, complacency, poor communication, and lack of
involvement.
In regard
to a fear of the unknown, employees are usually afraid of how a
change will impact them. For example, their own job or pay will
face the possibility of change, and it is also possible that the
employees may even face termination or demotion. The term
complacency refers to the employees being unaffected by the change,
and may contribute to employees being indifferent about what
management would like for them to change. These specific
individuals will do the bare minimum, and be on their way. As for
poor communication, a lack of clear direction will also cause
employees a good amount of confusion, which can lead to them not
being sure what is expected of them, and can lead to them being
passively or aggressively reluctant to change. Finally, a lack of
involvement refers to the importance of involving the entire team
in process of the organizational change.
For
example, as a front of house manager at the restaurant I used to
work at, I saw a huge need for cultural change to be implemented.
There were many other operational changes necessary, however we
could not tackle the issues together because everyone was divided
due to denied promotions, pay discrepancies and a lack of
motivation. Eventually our employee turnover rate almost tripled in
my department. As a higher-level manager, I would have tried to
repair the weak organizational culture by attempting to tackle
majority of the issues as they became more prominent.
Impact of Change on Strong Organizational Culture
A
company’s culture is the DNA of the organization, and a strong
culture is deeply engrained in the way a company conducts its
business. There is cohesion around traditions, rituals, behavioral
rules, and beliefs, and they usually will have more than one
prominent leader who will articulate their rules, rituals,
traditions and beliefs that are in line with the customer needs and
the company as a whole. A strong organizational culture may not pay
off financially from a short-term perspective, but the long-term
results will be positive when you have happy and loyal employees
(Dizik, 2016). To convert a weak organizational culture into a
strong organizational culture, there are a few key details to focus
on. First, as a manager myself, I would focus on the wellbeing of
my employees before anything. An organization should begin by
implementing a clear mission and vision statement that includes the
company’s values. Employees should know what their direct manager
or organization expects of them in terms of productivity and
conduct, and how they can achieve those expectations or objectives.
This step will give employees a sense of purpose and understanding
of the managerial goals or objectives they should strive to achieve
on a daily basis.
Second, a
manager or organization should have a clear and concise code of
conduct. The code of conduct will set guidelines that will be used
by all employees to specify how employees should conduct themselves
when interacting with one another. The code of conduct should also
bring the behavior of each employee into alignment with what the
company goals are in dealing with day-to-day client, partner and
third-party interactions. In other words, it should specify the
behaviors or actions that should and should not be said or
done.
Third,
a company should focus on pursuing a collaborative teamwork
environment within the workplace. It is important to push for a
synergistic environment, and to employ managers that will help
employees work together as a team. Also, a company should be able
to face challenges and adapt to constant change. When change
arises, employees are usually distracted by the impending fear of
the unknown. This fear debilitates development, and distracts
employees from the mission and vision of the company, but by
keeping a strong organizational culture, the organization should be
able to face certain challenges with ease and advance through tough
times.
Lastly, organizations should offer a safe and healthy workplace for
all employees. A safe and healthy environment demonstrates the
corporate and social responsibility of the corporation for their
employees. The well-being of the employees is just as much, if not
more important than the high standards for product results.
Physically and mentally, employees should feel well taken care of.
But beyond that is the enhancement of their skills and talents
through healthy venues. A safe and healthy work environment makes
employees want to work harder, show up on time and stay motivated
to finish the job at hand with utmost care.
Maintaining a Strong Culture & the Future of the
Organization
An organization’s culture can be seen as the foundation and driving
force behind its practices, goals, and achievements. One of the
main challenges is being able to comply with the company culture at
any given moment, because changes do occur that can have either a
positive or negative effect on the culture of the workplace and its
employees. According to Chapter 16, it states that “organizational
development is an ongoing process because an organization cannot
remain static and be effective. In today’s changing environment,
organizations must develop adaptive mechanisms and anticipative
management systems,” (Brown 2011). This is true, because consumer
preferences, the economy and supply chain systems are constantly
changing, and these operations are a crucial part in the overall
functionality of an organization. For a company’s culture to be
able to remain strong throughout times of change, there needs to be
a strong management system in place. Leaders of the corporation
need to be headstrong with unique and effective strategies that
will uphold the foundation of the company.
Second, there should be a clear understanding of the ethics and
values that remain true to the organization’s structure. Employees
should consent to abide by this aspect of the work culture no
matter what changes occur. Furthermore, relationships and a proper
code of conduct need to be implemented. Given a circumstance, as if
I were to be in a managerial position and had to handle changes
that could affect the culture of my own team, I would be sure to
inform my employees of what changes have or could be taking place
that may have a direct impact on our company or team. Then, I would
demonstrate how our organizational culture will successfully adapt
to that change, and remain vigorous so that our working system,
values, mission and procedures do not fail under the pressure of
those changes. Workshops, programs and orientations are vital tools
that can be used to make sure that employees stay up to date and be
reminded of the culture so they can perform their duties for the
company.
1. The four key things that I have learned after going through the topic are as follows:
2. The topic Organizational Culture and its Effect on the Corporate Environment relates to every organization and affects the morale of every employee. It affects my present workplace as well. The organization with which I am working is a College where different courses are run. The topic relates to my organization in the following ways:
3. The paper so presented highlights the meaning of organizational culture and how important it is to maintain a strong organizational culture. The author says that culture in an organization can be strong or it can be week. It is right on the terms that a strong organizational culture will result into a strong place for the employees with improved level of loyalty for the business, increased morale and high level of productivity.
On the other hand a week organizational culture will lead to low employee morale and less level of loyalty on the part of the employees. This will also lead to increased level of resistance for change, poor communication level between employees and management, lack of enjoyment in the workplace and lack of learning and development initiatives taken for the welfare of the employees.
In order to maintain proper quality in the workplace it is very important to follow ethics and moral values by the managers and proper and continuous follow up is important in order to maintain a strong organizational culture. Moreover high level of communication and involvement of the employees is very important for consistent and long lasting strong culture in the organization.