Question

In: Operations Management

*After leaving work one night, Bill decided to stop at local bar to have a few...

*After leaving work one night, Bill decided to stop at local bar to have a few drinks before he got home. Bill had one drink too many and become intoxicated. Nevertheless, Bill though he was able to drive home. On his way home, Bill swerved to avoid hitting a little boy in the street and hit Melissa with his car. Melissa broke her leg and wants to sue Bill. Can Bill be held liable under tort law and criminal law? If so, explain in details the importances differences between tort law and criminal law. Be sure to include in your answer (1) who may commence an action against; (2) who has the burden of proof in the tort action and criminal action; (3) the standard of proof required to prove each action; (4) and the possible consequences Bill faces as a result of his conduct.

*Using the sane fact above, discuss in some details the elements of negligence that Melissa must prove by a preponderance of the evidence to find Bill liable for her damages. Be sure to use the facts to establish each of the neccesary elements for an action of negligence.

Solutions

Expert Solution

TORT LAW:- TORT, in jurisdictions law means a civilian performing wrong/incorrect activity that has caused somebody else to suffer or harm with the action of activity. This is simply a civil wrong. In laws, torts are grounds for lawsuits to compensate the harmed party for any injuries/damages suffered by the Tortfeasor(the person who commits the wrong civil activity). The types of TORTS are negligence, intentional & strict liability. It has high probability that it is caused unintentionally.

CRIMINAL LAW:- CRINIMAL, in jurisdictions means a person conducting crime such as murder, threatening, theft of property, rapes. Criminal Law, is the body of law that defines criminal offenses, regulates the charges, trial of suspects & then penalize as needed & required. This is only one law which can help societies secure their individual interest & any harm done to them. These crimes are held because of a motive & hence are intentional.

Bill can held under TORT law, since as per the scenario stated, he did not had any intention of hitting Melissa. It was an accident that has happened, that too while saving a little boy, he hit Melissa. Bill was drunk too & accidentally hit Melissa, which has broken her leg…so Melissa can sue Bill. Melissa will begin an action against bill under TORT law since there is no criminal signs were observed during the activity. Melissa will prove by showing the medical bills due to injury happened in her leg on the same day as that of accident. As a consequence, Bill might have to reimburse the amount of the hospital bills & the other expenses if any; Usually such incident are sorted by insurance companies & individuals.

If in this scenario, Bill might have run after hitting Melissa then Bill could have been charged as criminal & would be escalated as an criminal case. In this case, Bill might have to pay heavy penalities & if severe damages would have been found, Bill might be even jailed.

Melissa would present the following proofs in order to justify the negligence of Bill:-

  1. She would present any witness who would be available at the time of accident & would prove the inappropriate driving of Bill.
  2. She would also state the fact that Bill was drunk & was driving.
  3. Hospital bills & other reports would present the level of injury/damage.

Related Solutions

Use IRAC to answer the following: Late one night after drinking heavily, Arnold and Carter decided...
Use IRAC to answer the following: Late one night after drinking heavily, Arnold and Carter decided that they would rob the local all-night convenience store. They drove Arnold’s truck to the store, entered, and yelled, “This is a stickup,” while brandishing their unloaded pistols. They discovered that the only persons in the store were Fred, who worked at the store, a customer, who was named Cher. Arnold became enraged, since he regarded Cher as his steady girlfriend and was jealous...
Required information SB Bill, Page, Larry, and Scott have decided... Bill, Page, Larry, and Scott have...
Required information SB Bill, Page, Larry, and Scott have decided... Bill, Page, Larry, and Scott have decided to terminate their partnership. The partnership's balance sheet at the time they decide to wind up is as follows: Cash $ 100,000 Accounts payable $ 100,000 Noncash Assets 300,000 Bill, Capital 25,000 Page, Capital 110,000 Larry, Capital 100,000 Scott, Capital 65,000 $ 400,000 Total $ 400,000 During the winding up of the partnership, the other assets are sold for $150,000 and the accounts...
Question 5 : The BT Partnership has decided to liquidate after an unsuccessful few years. The...
Question 5 : The BT Partnership has decided to liquidate after an unsuccessful few years. The following balance sheet is shown for BT Partnership after the closing of the business and the preparation of financial statements on December 31, 2020. The partners share income and losses equally. Cash $1,000 Notes Payable $500 Truck 10,000 Less: Accumulated Depreciation 5,000 Bachman, Capital 3,000 Turner, Capital 2,500 Total Assets $6,000 Total Liabilities and Partner's equity $6,000 BT Partnerships Balance Sheet December 31, 2020...
Jerry and a group of friends have decided to set up an online game night for...
Jerry and a group of friends have decided to set up an online game night for this Wednesday. Most of the games they will play involve a standard deck of playing cards (52 card deck). As such, Jerry hopes to use what he's learning in statistics class to gain an upper hand. **For reference, a standard deck of playing cards consists of 52 cards. Each card is one of the 4 suits: spade, heart, diamond, or club. Each suit contains...
A few days after you have completed the streak plate method, you observe not one single...
A few days after you have completed the streak plate method, you observe not one single isolated colony on the TSA plate. Explain why this may have happened. How does dental plaque form? How does tooth decay occur?
You and your roommates have decided to go to a fraternity party on Saturday night. You...
You and your roommates have decided to go to a fraternity party on Saturday night. You arrive at the fraternity house and see another classmate, Jenn, from your psychology class. You go over to say hello and see what she thought of the first exam, but Jenn seems to be acting very strangely. She starts describing fantastic colors made by the lights and how the dance floor is a beautiful sea of diamonds. You take a look around and realize...
1. Researchers want to study the size of the local raccoon population. On one night, 25...
1. Researchers want to study the size of the local raccoon population. On one night, 25 animals were caught, tagged, and then released. Over the next several weeks, 3 samples of 15 were taken. The first time, 8 raccoons were tagged. The next time, 6 raccoons had tags. On the final time, 9 raccoons had tags. What would you report as the size of the raccoon population? 2. Research on a new medication shows it is 85% effective in relieving...
You have decided that the Fit Stop would be well suited to Organizational Performance Pay. Select...
You have decided that the Fit Stop would be well suited to Organizational Performance Pay. Select the specific organizational performance pay plan that would seem to work best; then design it, describing specifically how you would deal with various design issues. When you are done, the plan should be ready for implementation.
Bill, Page, Larry, and Scott have decided to terminate their partnership. The partnership's balance sheet at...
Bill, Page, Larry, and Scott have decided to terminate their partnership. The partnership's balance sheet at the time they decide to wind up is as follows: ASSETS: Cash $100,000 Noncash assets 300,000 LIABILITIES: Payables $100,000 CAPITAL ACCOUNTS: Bill, capital $25,000 Page, capital 110,000 Larry, capital 100,000 Scott, capital 65,000 During the winding up of the partnership, the other assets are sold for $250,000 and the accounts payable are paid. Page and Larry are personally solvent, but Bill and Scott are...
After a recent sale of your business, you decided to donate $1 million to your local...
After a recent sale of your business, you decided to donate $1 million to your local university to fund a scholarship fund. Assume the university can earn 6% interest rate on its investments. You want the scholarship to be paid out annually, and the first scholarship to be paid out in one year. You also want that the annual scholarship amount increases with inflation thereafter. The inflation is expected at 2%. What will be the amount of the first year...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT