In the US it is illegal to sell your Kidney (you only need one so everyone...

In the US it is illegal to sell your Kidney (you only need one so everyone could sell one to someone who needed it). This effectively imposes a price ceiling of $0 in this market.

a. What type of market distortion does this policy cause? What are the consequences of this ban?

b. How does lifting the ban (that is making it legal to sell your kidney and allowing market forces to determine price and quantity) solve this distortion? Why would this be more efficient from an economist’s point of view?

c. Discuss the differences between (a) and (b). Think about the participants in the market. Who are the producers and who are the consumers of kidneys? If (b) is more efficient why do we maintain the ban? Justify the ban on selling one’s organs.

Expert Solution

1. Price ceilings prevent a price from rising above a certain level.

When a price ceiling is set below the equilibrium price, quantity demanded will exceed quantity supplied, and excess demand or shortages will result.

This shortage will lead to black markets or illegal organ trafficking. Poor people would be forced into organ sale. Sometimes, organ might be even stolen without a person's consent.

2. When ban on Kidney sale is taken away. The problem of excess demand can be avoided. The people who are able and willing to sell their Kidney would be able to do it. This will be more efficient as people who are willing to sell their Kidney will be offered payment.

3. The producers are the people who are healthy and has two functioning kidneys. The consumers are the people who are sick and who require Kidney for transplant. From the point of view of Economists, the market system of Kidney sale is more efficient.

But we cannot justify the sale of organs from a humanitarian perspective. Human beings have a dignity. Their organs should also be handled with dignity, When we are donating Kidney, that is a charity. But we cannot legalise organ sale because if we do so, then we might up end up objectifying human body.

RATE it with a Thumbs up

Rahul Sunny answered 1 year ago

In Afghanistan, coffee is illegal, so people sell coffee beans on the black market. The demand...

In Afghanistan, coffee is illegal, so people sell coffee beans on the black market. The demand for coffee beans (Y) is YD = 24 – P and the supply for coffee beans is YS = 4P. Estimate the equilibrium price and quantity in the black market. Use a graph to support your answer. This is a basic algebra equation (solve for P) P=price. If you remember from your chapter 4 reading: Yd=Ys 24-P=4P 24=4P+P 24=5P P=24/5 P=4.8 Once we solve...

discuss Kidney Donation Systems Around the World (not the us), no need to add a graph...

discuss Kidney Donation Systems Around the World (not the us), no need to add a graph here. Explore the policies that are currently implemented across the globe (i.e. some discussed in the articles include - routine removal, presumed consent, organ donor points, "no give, no take", etc.). Evaluate the limitations of these policies. Also consider how these policies fare in terms of the efficiency vs. equity debate. (You do not need to critique them all, just select from 2 or...

Is buying/selling/consuming marijuana illegal? Can you enforce contracts whose objective is illegal? If so, how do...

Is buying/selling/consuming marijuana illegal? Can you enforce contracts whose objective is illegal? If so, how do marijuana producers (if they can) enforce their sales contracts?

THERE IS NO MORE INFO, ONLY THIS, THANK YOU 2. It is illegal for any two...

THERE IS NO MORE INFO, ONLY THIS, THANK YOU 2. It is illegal for any two firms that sell similar products to engage in price fixing agreements. Violating the anti-trust laws can bring both civil and criminal prosecutions. Nevertheless, price fixing does take place. Examples would be found at the service plazas along the NY State Thruway and the NJ Turnpike. Each location has a small number of fast-food restaurants. Each fast-food restaurant belongs to a different firm, which should...

You need a new oven for your bakery. Your current oven is worn out so you...

You need a new oven for your bakery. Your current oven is worn out so you are trying to decide which one of two ovens to buy as a replacement. Whichever oven you purchase will be replaced after its useful life. Oven A costs $25,000 and costs $3,000 a year to operate over an 8-year life. Oven B costs $20,000 and costs $4,500 a year to operate over a 6-year life. Given this information, which one of the following statements...

Imagine that you now need to sell your company's products to consumers living in a region...

Imagine that you now need to sell your company's products to consumers living in a region dominated by lesser developed countries (LDC's). By what criteria would you decide to EXPORT to these countries? LICENSE production of your products to local manufacturers? INVEST company capital to build a manufacturing plant?

You have a large gain on one of your Treasuries and want to sell it, but...

You have a large gain on one of your Treasuries and want to sell it, but you would like to defer the gain until the next tax year. How could you hedge in this situation? Multiple Choice Sell a Treasury futures contract. Buy a Treasury futures contract.

a) You went on spring vacation and missed school so you need to make up your...

a) You went on spring vacation and missed school so you need to make up your homework. You are missing 4 math assignments and 2 science assignments and 3 social studies assignments. What is the probability that the assignments from each class will be completed together (i.e. all of one class, then all of another class, then all of another class)? Round to 4 decimals. b) A family is planning on having 5 children. A baby food company told the...

Five years later, you are offered your dream job in Costa Rica. You need to sell...

Five years later, you are offered your dream job in Costa Rica. You need to sell this house in order to purchase a new one where you are moving. Rents have increased since you purchased the home and you estimate that the home will rent for $20,400 per year (net). You have found a high quality tenant willing to sign a five year lease under the following conditions. Rent will be $$20,400 each year for the first three years, and...

Programming in C (not C++) ## Requirements Only need to edit the challenge.c You have one...

Programming in C (not C++) ## Requirements Only need to edit the challenge.c You have one function to implement: void fork_exec(char** argv): This takes in an array of strings representing arguments. The first argument is the filename of an executable (which will be given as a relative filepath, such as "./a") The remaining terms would be arguments for said executable. The array is null terminated You need to fork your process. The child needs to call exec (rather, a variant...

Question