Question

In: Physics

: Our final topic of the semester was informal fallacies. We talked about several types of...

: Our final topic of the semester was informal fallacies. We talked about several types of common fallacies and ways of diagnosing what went wrong in each. In these cases where someone provides a fallacious argument, people reason in accordance with bad arguments. Throughout the semester you have also learned several tools for identifying and diagnosing what makes arguments good. Describe an instance of bad reasoning that you have encountered or that you think is common using the tools we have developed: do you think it is it the result of a fallacy we have discussed, or something else? This example can be as basic or banal as you like, but try to think of more real world examples here rather than tv shows or ads. Then, describe how you would now respond and react to such arguments: how would you try to change the mind of someone who offered such reasoning? What good arguments might you offer to change their mind. How could you convince them, given what you now know about what makes an argument good, that what they argued or claim was mistaken? Try to appeal to the concepts we introduced and what they mean: deductive validity, inductive strength, the purposes of arguments, etc.

Solutions

Expert Solution

q.no1 Describe an instance of bad reasoning that you have encountered or that you think is common using the tools we have developed: do you think it is it the result of a fallacy we have discussed, or something else?

Ans   An informal fallacy occurs because of an error in reasoning, lets discuss one informal fallacy that we commonly encounter i.e begging the question (petitio principii).

abhishek: We know if you place a support near COM(center of mass ) then more chances that it can be become equilibrium or balanced condition.

roger: How do we know which object has where Center of mass?

abhishek: where they are perfectally ballanced.

yes i think it is a result of fallicy that we have discussed because in first statement by abhishek evevryone will belive that he's right but falllacy will come in second statement itself beacuse not every one will think that it can only balance by com it can also balalnced by applying torque at different point to make it balance.

Q.NO.2 Describe how you would now respond and react to such arguments: how would you try to change the mind of someone who offered such reasoning? What good arguments might you offer to change their mind. How could you convince them, given what you now know about what makes an argument good, that what they argued or claim was mistaken?

ANS: we can react to such arguments by providing the details of the subject here i used example of science so i will just clarify the upcomming doubt they have by resisting them to accept my thought onthis very hardly thats what you can do . Here i will offer some good arguments like we know COM is very unique point in the body where all mass concentrated if you place a support through it then torque itself will be zero because Torque = force x perpendicular distance . here distance will be zero therefor torque will be zero . Providing the materilistic concent regarding the argument will allows you to stength your arguments .

deductive validity A deductive argument is good if and only if it is both valid, and all of its premises are actually true. Otherwise, a deductive argument is not so good.

inductively strong argument is an argument in which it is improbable that its conclusion is false given that its premises are true.

p.s if you liked the ans do give upvote...


Related Solutions

functionalist talked about several types of cells,what were they?
functionalist talked about several types of cells,what were they?
1.Symbiosis means “living together” and we talked about several types of symbiotic interactions that happen in...
1.Symbiosis means “living together” and we talked about several types of symbiotic interactions that happen in communities. Name ONE type of symbiotic interaction and give me an example. 2.What happens to energy as it moves through the trophic levels of an ecosystem? What happens to nutrients as they move through an ecosystem?
Throughout the semester we talked about the challenges that different groups of organisms had to overcome...
Throughout the semester we talked about the challenges that different groups of organisms had to overcome as they evolved to live in terrestrial environments. What do you see as the biggest obstacles that different groups of organisms had to overcome as they evolved to live on land?  Describe ways in which different groups (including plants, arthropodsand vertebrates) were able to meet these challenges. (20 pts)
Q- We have discussed the topic “Rationale of Regulations “ in which we talked about the...
Q- We have discussed the topic “Rationale of Regulations “ in which we talked about the reasons for having regulations in a given country. Rationale of Regulations including issues of monopoly, windfall profits, externalities, social policy, information inadequacies, continuity and availability of services, anti-competitive behavior and predatory pricing, public goods and moral hazard, unequal bargaining power, scarcity and distribution of wealth, rationalization and coordination, and planning. Examine only one of the above Rationale of Regulations by providing a definition, an...
In our class we talked about impacts of COVID on the Canadian economy. by referring to...
In our class we talked about impacts of COVID on the Canadian economy. by referring to the class discussion explain possible impacts of COVID on AD and SRAS and appropriate polices for dealing with the problem.  
This question is about Chapter 13 Aggregate Planning. We talked about two types of options for...
This question is about Chapter 13 Aggregate Planning. We talked about two types of options for aggregate planning strategies. What are the two types of options, and what do they each include?
During the semester, we talked a lot of impact of People, Process and Technology. All of...
During the semester, we talked a lot of impact of People, Process and Technology. All of the above come together to either help Enterprises thrive in business or vanish. One important point of intersection is the relationship between the Enterprise Structure and Culture. There is a general assumption that the Enterprise structure and Enterprise culture impact each other. In a domain of your choice, with examples, First, outline the mechanism through which Enterprise Culture impacts the design of Enterprise Structure,...
We talked about the genes controlling our ability to digest lactose, the sugar found in milk....
We talked about the genes controlling our ability to digest lactose, the sugar found in milk. Collectively the enzymes produced by the set of genes involved are called lactase. "Lactose intolerance" describes the most common condition in human adults, which is an inability to digest lactose because lactase is not produced. These people could all produce lactase as infants, however, so they have the genes needed to produce functional enzymes. Somehow the regulation of expression of the genes changes as...
Describe the functions of the major types of membrane proteins that we talked about receptors, enzymes,...
Describe the functions of the major types of membrane proteins that we talked about receptors, enzymes, ion channels, gated ion channels, cell identity markers, cell adhesion molecules, carriers, and pumps. Understand that these are overlapping functional categories.
We are learning in this topic about adjusting entries. If our business affairs are to be...
We are learning in this topic about adjusting entries. If our business affairs are to be conducted in a godly manner, we could consider Luke 16:12: "And if you have not been trustworthy with someone else's property, who will give you property of your own?" Think about this verse, and explain how this might be applied to the topic of adjusting entries.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT