Question

In: Statistics and Probability

Spurious correlation refers to the apparent relationship between variables that either have no true relationship or...

Spurious correlation refers to the apparent relationship between variables that either have no true relationship or are related to other variables that have not been measured. One widely publicized stock market indicator that is an example of spurious correlation is the relationship between the winner of a major sports championship and the performance of a stock index in that year. The​ "indicator" states that when a team from a particular conference wins the​ championship, the stock index will increase in that year. Since the first championship was​ held, the indicator has been correct 44 out of 56 times. Assuming that this indicator is a random event with no predictive​ value, you would expect that the indicator would be correct​ 50% of the time.

a. What is the probability that the indicator would be correct 44 or more times in 56 years?

b. What does this tell you about the usefulness of this indicator?

Solutions

Expert Solution

Answer:-

Given that:-

The indicator has been correct 44 out of 56 times. Assuming that this indicator is a random event with no predictive​ value, you would expect that the indicator would be correct​ 50% of the time.

Here ,it follows Binomial distribution. Since the following conditions.

1.The number of sample observations is finite and independent. That is ,n = 56

2.The probability of success is known . That is p = 0.50

Therefore, the probability mass unction as follows:

a) Find  the probability that the indicator would be correct 44 or more times in 56 years.

=0+0.00000206+.....+0+0

=0.00000206

b) The probability that the indicator would be correct 44or more than times in 56 years is 0.00000206. This probability is very small .Thus it can be concluded that the indicator is not much useful as it depends on a third hidden variable.


Related Solutions

For an inverse relationship between two variables, the sign of the correlation coefficient is "+" TRUE...
For an inverse relationship between two variables, the sign of the correlation coefficient is "+" TRUE OR FALSE
Correlation, Causality, and Spurious Relationship Collapse Let’s discuss correlation and causality. To explain this, we can...
Correlation, Causality, and Spurious Relationship Collapse Let’s discuss correlation and causality. To explain this, we can use an example of illness. When doctors see some symptoms in the patient, they may or may not be clear what disease the patient has. If doctors know what disease the patient has, they can cure the disease. However, often doctors treat symptoms without curing the disease. They are dealing with a correlation, not causality. Do you see the difference between correlation and causality?...
What is/are true about the correlation between the two variables? I. It measures the strength of...
What is/are true about the correlation between the two variables? I. It measures the strength of the linear relation between the variables, as seen in the roundness/flatness of the scatterplot between the two variables. II. If the correlation equals 0, then there is no relation between the two variables. III. If the correlation is very high, then there is a strong causal relation between the two variables. a. l only b. II only c. I and III d. I and...
A linear relationship exists between 2 quantitative variables. The correlation coefficient is -0.14. Which of the...
A linear relationship exists between 2 quantitative variables. The correlation coefficient is -0.14. Which of the following is true? A transformation should be done to try to make the correlation coefficient positive and closer to 1. There is no evidence to indicate a relationship exists between the two variables because of the negative correlation coefficient. This indicates a strong relationship between the two variables. This indicates a weak relationship between the two variables. This is impossible as correlation coefficients can’t...
Perform one correlation between two independent variables, such as Age and Relationship with Coworkers. Perform the...
Perform one correlation between two independent variables, such as Age and Relationship with Coworkers. Perform the second correlation on an independent variable (such as Relationship with Direct Supervisor) and the dependent variable (such as Workplace Happiness Rating. Gender Age Supervisor Telecommute Coworkers Happiness Engagement Overall Rating 1 29 1 1 2 7 8 15 2 32 4 1 3 9 10 19 1 39 1 1 1 4 5 8 1 25 2 1 2 5 8 13 1 27...
CASE STUDY 2: Correlation and Regression are investigating the relationship between two continuous variables such as...
CASE STUDY 2: Correlation and Regression are investigating the relationship between two continuous variables such as height and weight, time and speed or the concentration of an injected drug and heart rate. a) In your opinion, discuss the importance of Correlation and Regression as a tools for analysis purposes. b) Find any correlation and regression that have been applied in business from the online platform. From the data you required to: i. State the Independent and Dependent Variable ii. Draw...
One of the major misconceptions about correlation is that a relationship between two variables means causation;...
One of the major misconceptions about correlation is that a relationship between two variables means causation; that is, one variable causes changes in the other variable. There is a particular tendency to make this causal error when the two variables seem to be related to each other. What is one instance where you have seen correlation misinterpreted as causation? Please describe.
1. The linear correlation coefficient r measures of the linear relationship between two variables. (a) Distance...
1. The linear correlation coefficient r measures of the linear relationship between two variables. (a) Distance (b) size (c) strength (d) direction 2. 10 pairs of sample data were obtained from a study which looked at household income and the number of people in the household who smoked (cigarettes). The value of the linear correlation coefficient r was computed and a result of - 0.989 was obtained. All of the following (below) are conclusions that can be drawn from the...
1. The linear correlation coefficient r measures of the linear relationship between two variables. (a) Distance...
1. The linear correlation coefficient r measures of the linear relationship between two variables. (a) Distance (b) size (c) strength (d) direction 2. 10 pairs of sample data were obtained from a study which looked at household income and the number of people in the household who smoked (cigarettes). The value of the linear correlation coefficient r was computed and a result of - 0.989 was obtained. All of the following (below) are conclusions that can be drawn from the...
1. The linear correlation coefficient r measures of the linear relationship between two variables. (a) Distance...
1. The linear correlation coefficient r measures of the linear relationship between two variables. (a) Distance (b) size (c) strength (d) direction 2. 10 pairs of sample data were obtained from a study which looked at household income and the number of people in the household who smoked (cigarettes). The value of the linear correlation coefficient r was computed and a result of - 0.989 was obtained. All of the following (below) are conclusions that can be drawn from the...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT