Case Study Duty-Oriented Reasoning: A Matter of Principle Juan and Joe are good friends. They both...

Case Study

Duty-Oriented Reasoning: A Matter of Principle

Juan and Joe are good friends. They both graduated from the same program and have gone to work in the same radiography department. Part of their duties is to be sure that the standby equipment is ready for service on the wards. Juan and Joe are working the night shift, and while playing around, Juan inadvertently bumps the equipment, tips it over, and breaks the standby instrument.

In that it was an accident, Juan asks you, as a friend, not to tell anyone it was his fault. “Accidents do happen.” The two of you switch out the equipment, sending the broken piece down to maintenance, and put a working instrument on standby.

In the morning your boss comes in and notices that the equipment has been sent down to maintenance. He asks what happened, and Juan says, “I dunno. Someone from out of the department must have bumped it or something.” The boss looks at you and asks you the same question.

Solve the problem using duty-oriented or principled reasoning. Remember that in this form of reasoning, it is not the consequences that are considered but rather the principles involved.
What principles are involved in this case?
Do any of the principles involved conflict with each other?
Do some principles have a higher value than others?

Expert Solution

1. In this case, though Juan and Joe are very good friends but ethically their core responsibility is to be sure that the standby equipment is ready for service on the wards. But this didn't happened because Juan inadvertently bumps the equipment, tips it over, and breaks the standby instrument.

2. Through a professional perspective, Juan and Joe both are suppose to be more truthful, responsible and dedicated to their profession as well as their seniors in the institution. However, Juan lied to his boss keeping his duty aside to escape from the accusation of breaking the standby instrument which is totally wrong from principle point of view

3. Yes surely the principle of honesty to the organization as well as seniors will get them involved in conflict with each other.

4. Without any doubt some principles have a higher value than others. According to me "Principle of Honesty" must be always kept higher than the "Principle of secrecy"

Nightingale answered 2 years ago

Case study 4 Mr. Ahmed and Mr. Mohammed have been good friends for a long time....

Case study 4 Mr. Ahmed and Mr. Mohammed have been good friends for a long time. They completed their Bachelor's in Ibra College of Technology. Mr. Ahmed was well versed in accounts and Mr. Mohammed had some knowledge in sales. They both came up with an idea to open a small venture on their own than getting employed in private companies. Hence they decided to open an organic fruits and vegetable shop focusing on a health-conscious target market in Alyat...

Messrs Addo Mensah, Joe Nkansah and Prosper Afenyo were good friends and decided to form a...

Messrs Addo Mensah, Joe Nkansah and Prosper Afenyo were good friends and decided to form a Partnership business called AKA partners. They contributed towards the capital of the firm in the ratio 1:1:1. The firm was duly registered and issued with a certificate of registration. The partners share profits and losses equally. After operating for ten (10) years, the partners do not trust each other and they have agreed to go their separate ways. The partners have come to you...

For this case study we will take up the matter of genetic testing for untreatable genetic...

For this case study we will take up the matter of genetic testing for untreatable genetic diseases. Huntington’s disease is a devastating genetic disorder with no known effective treatment. However a test for detecting the HD gene is available and relatively inexpensive to administer. Carriers of the HD gene typically develop symptoms in the prime of their life that range across a variety of physical and emotional disorders. In advanced stages they are rendered helpless against involuntary muscle spasms throughout...

Case study: The Good, the Bad and the Ugly - A Story of Vadym Hetman As...

Case study: The Good, the Bad and the Ugly - A Story of Vadym Hetman As CEO of Avani International, Hetman headed the growth of a corporate giant. At its peak, Avani was gobbling up 200 companies a year. Under his leadership, the value of Avani increased 70-fold. In 2011, Hetman proclaimed his desire to be remembered as the world greatest business executive. Things turn sour when Hetman and his former chief financial officer were accused of running criminal enterprise...

Case Study Salvador, Frida, Wassily, Leonardo and Jackson became friends while they were in the same...

Case Study Salvador, Frida, Wassily, Leonardo and Jackson became friends while they were in the same year group at art school. They all graduated in 2015, and together set up a small business selling low-priced arts supplies, initially from a market stall in Bradford before they developed an online shop. The business slowly grew, and they recognised that there was a demand for their competitively priced products. They identified a need for investment in their business in order to reach...

Put-Call Parity Case Study The put option of Joe Inc. is currently trading at $2.50 while...

Put-Call Parity Case Study The put option of Joe Inc. is currently trading at $2.50 while the call option premium is $7.50. Both the put and the call have an exercise price of $25. Joe Inc. stock is currently trading at $32.25 and the risk free rate is 3%. The options will expire in one month. I. An investor applies a protective put strategy by buying the put option of Joe Inc. to protect his holding of the company’s stock....

I'm not sure if this is a good issue statement for short case study. Thanks for...

I'm not sure if this is a good issue statement for short case study. Thanks for the help! An American multinational widely diversified media and entertainment organization, Disney Company which started their journey from 1923 are now recognized as one of the most successful enterprise in the century. Bob Iger who has lead the company with his magical, yet fundamental and strong business strategy to overcome the barriers that Disney faced in the last ten years in his career as...

Case Study: After graduating from college, best friends Sally and Sandy decided to open a landscaping...

Case Study: After graduating from college, best friends Sally and Sandy decided to open a landscaping business. Sally had majored in accounting, so she would handle the business’ financial operations. Sandy, who had majored in landscaping, would handle the landscaping operations. Sandy worked with clients to recommend plants, develop and implement landscape plans, and run the retail store that featured seasonal plants and landscaping supplies. Sally’s responsibilities were to review the financial reports and monitor the business’ accounts, both accounts...

business law and ethics Case Study Salvador, Frida, Wassily, Leonardo and Jackson became friends while they...

business law and ethics Case Study Salvador, Frida, Wassily, Leonardo and Jackson became friends while they were in the same year group at art school. They all graduated in 2015, and together set up a small business selling low-priced arts supplies, initially from a market stall in Bradford before they developed an online shop. The business slowly grew, and they recognised that there was a demand for their competitively priced products. They identified a need for investment in their business...

Case Study: 2 (10 marks) Looking at the following conversation between two friends, file the tax...

Case Study: 2 Looking at the following conversation between two friends, file the tax returns of Mr. Ahmed with correct taxable income and tax liabilities: Mr. Abdullah: Good morning Mr. Ahmed. After a very long time. How are you? How is your Family?..... Mr. Ahmed: Good morning brother, everyone is fit and fine except me….. Mr. Abdullah: What happened Ahmed? You are looking so worried Mr. Ahmed: I have to file my tax returns and my accountant has left it...

Question