Question

In: Economics

Read, analyze, and comment on the reading and statement in green below: The '77 Cents on...

Read, analyze, and comment on the reading and statement in green below:

The '77 Cents on the Dollar' Myth About Women's Pay

Once education, marital status, and occupations are considered, the "gender wage gap" all but disappears.

April 8 is "Equal Pay Day," an annual event to raise awareness regarding the so-called gender wage gap. As President Obama said in the State of the Union address, women "still make 77 cents for every dollar a man earns," a claim echoed by the National Committee on Pay Equity, the American Association of University Women and other progressive groups.

The 23% gap implies that women work an extra 68 days to earn the same pay as a man. Mr. Obama advocates allowing women to sue for wage discrimination, with employers bearing the burden of proving they did not discriminate. But the numbers bandied about to make the claim of widespread discrimination are fundamentally misleading and economically illogical.

In its annual report, "Highlights of Women's Earnings in 2012," the Bureau of Labor Statistics states that "In 2012, women who were full-time wage and salary workers had median usual weekly earnings of $691. On average in 2012, women made about 81% of the median earnings of male full-time wage and salary workers ($854)." Give or take a few percentage points, the BLS appears to support the president's claim.

But every "full-time" worker, as the BLS notes, is not the same: Men were almost twice as likely as women to work more than 40 hours a week, and women almost twice as likely to work only 35 to 39 hours per week. Once that is taken into consideration, the pay gap begins to shrink. Women who worked a 40-hour week earned 88% of male earnings.

Then there is the issue of marriage and children. The BLS reports that single women who have never married earned 96% of men's earnings in 2012.

The supposed pay gap appears when marriage and children enter the picture. Child care takes mothers out of the labor market, so when they return they have less work experience than similarly-aged males. Many working mothers seek jobs that provide greater flexibility, such as telecommuting or flexible hours. Not all jobs can be flexible, and all other things being equal, those which are will pay less than those that do not.

Education also matters. Even within groups with the same educational attainment, women often choose fields of study, such as sociology, liberal arts or psychology, that pay less in the labor market. Men are more likely to major in finance, accounting or engineering. And as the American Association of University Women reports, men are four times more likely to bargain over salaries once they enter the job market.

Risk is another factor. Nearly all the most dangerous occupations, such as loggers or iron workers, are majority male and 92% of work-related deaths in 2012 were to men. Dangerous jobs tend to pay higher salaries to attract workers. Also: Males are more likely to pursue occupations where compensation is risky from year to year, such as law and finance. Research shows that average pay in such jobs is higher to compensate for that risk.

While the BLS reports that full-time female workers earned 81% of full-time males, that is very different than saying that women earned 81% of what men earned for doing the same jobs, while working the same hours, with the same level of risk, with the same educational background and the same years of continuous, uninterrupted work experience, and assuming no gender differences in family roles like child care. In a more comprehensive study that controlled for most of these relevant variables simultaneously—such as that from economists June and Dave O'Neill for the American Enterprise Institute in 2012—nearly all of the 23% raw gender pay gap cited by Mr. Obama can be attributed to factors other than discrimination. The O'Neills conclude that, "labor market discrimination is unlikely to account for more than 5% but may not be present at all."

These gender-disparity claims are also economically illogical. If women were paid 77 cents on the dollar, a profit-oriented firm could dramatically cut labor costs by replacing male employees with females. Progressives assume that businesses nickel-and-dime suppliers, customers, consultants, anyone with whom they come into contact—yet ignore a great opportunity to reduce wages costs by 23%. They don't ignore the opportunity because it doesn't exist. Women are not in fact paid 77 cents on the dollar for doing the same work as men.

Administration officials are (very) occasionally challenged on their discrimination claims. The reply is that even if lower average female pay is a result of women's choices, those choices are themselves driven by discrimination. Yet the choice of college major is quite free, and many colleges recruit women into high-paying science or math majors. Likewise, many women prefer to stay home with their children. If doing so allows their husbands to maximize their own earnings, it's not clear that the families are worse off. It makes no sense to sue employers for choices made by women years or decades earlier.

The administration's claims regarding the gender pay gap are faulty, and its proposal to make it easier for women to sue employers for equal pay would create a disincentive for firms to hire women.

Mr. Perry is a scholar at the American Enterprise Institute and professor of economics and finance

Solutions

Expert Solution

The 77 Cents on the dollar myth definitely gives a different perspective regarding the male female wage gap in the labor market. This is indeed a case which shows statistics can be manipulated to create a favorable argument for a motion. But one should keep in mind that critical analysis can bring put light on causal factors which can often be overlooked in the scrutiny and emphasis of statistics.

The article brings about some relevant points regarding the duration of employment, risk involved, family planning, educational background etc. It is interesting to note that all these factors seem to contribute significantly in the improvement of wages. Men on average tend to be involved in more riskier jobs and spend more work hours than women. Also, men tend to specialise in subjects which are higher paying whereas women often choose field of study like sociology and psychology which pay less in the labour market.

The claim that "labor market discrimination is unlikely to account for more than 5% but man not be present at all" may not show the complete picture. This is because many choices and decisions women make are a product of the societal hierarchy. Patriarchy continues to persist in the society in some way or another even if males are unwilling to accept it. Thus a nature selection of roles and duties over the years means that women cannot overcome the wage gap through statistical prescriptions. The challenge of administrative claims regarding male-female wage gap is certainly warranted based on evidence but the arguments should also consider other social factors which do not come under the domain of statistics.

Kindly thumbs up if answer was helpful


Related Solutions

Read and comment about the following statement and question. The Benefit – Cost analysis is a...
Read and comment about the following statement and question. The Benefit – Cost analysis is a well – rooted method of evaluating public projects (Rigs, J, & West, T., 1986, page 234.). Do you think the government use this economic method or use other criteria for project evaluation?
Read, analyze, and comment on the following readings which include the classic: I, Pencil: “Eloquent. Extraordinary....
Read, analyze, and comment on the following readings which include the classic: I, Pencil: “Eloquent. Extraordinary. Timeless. Paradigm-shifting. Classic. Half a century after it first appeared, Leonard Read’s ‘I, Pencil’ still evokes such adjectives of praise. Rightfully so, for this little essay opens eyes and minds among people of all ages. Many first-time readers never see the world quite the same again.” ~ Lawrence W. Reed Hundreds of thousands of Americans of all ages continue to enjoy this simple and...
Read, analyze, and comment on the following readings which include the classic: I, Pencil: “Eloquent. Extraordinary....
Read, analyze, and comment on the following readings which include the classic: I, Pencil: “Eloquent. Extraordinary. Timeless. Paradigm-shifting. Classic. Half a century after it first appeared, Leonard Read’s ‘I, Pencil’ still evokes such adjectives of praise. Rightfully so, for this little essay opens eyes and minds among people of all ages. Many first-time readers never see the world quite the same again.” ~ Lawrence W. Reed Hundreds of thousands of Americans of all ages continue to enjoy this simple and...
Read and comment about the following statement and question: Why is so important to know the...
Read and comment about the following statement and question: Why is so important to know the variety of costs to be considered in an engineering economic analysis?(Sullivan W., Wicks E. & Patrick C., 2012, page 21.).
analyze the comment "follow the money" to understand priorities in public policy analyze the comment "follow...
analyze the comment "follow the money" to understand priorities in public policy analyze the comment "follow the money " in understanding priorities in public policy
What is the output produced by each statement below? If the statement causes an error, comment...
What is the output produced by each statement below? If the statement causes an error, comment it out and write either "compiler error" or "runtime error" as appropriate. For each line make your guess and then move the open comment down a line to test your theory. public class Main { public static void main(String[] args) { First var1 = new Second(); First var2 = new Third(); First var3 = new Fourth(); Second var4 = new Third(); Object var5 =...
Read the article below and as you’re reading it translate how the ‘utility’ concepts in this...
Read the article below and as you’re reading it translate how the ‘utility’ concepts in this week’s lesson are applied in the article. Note, for example, that the author talks about ‘value’ relative to price. This indicates to you that ‘utility’ is sometimes referred to as ‘value’ by some marketers. Hall, Doug. (Dec 13, 2007). Jump Start: Perceiving is Believing. Bloomberg Business Week. Preview the document Now, look for a news headline that illustrates basic utility concepts (such as MU,...
Read Finance in Action Ethics on page 232: "LIBOR Price-Fixing Scandal" please comment after reading.
Read Finance in Action Ethics on page 232: "LIBOR Price-Fixing Scandal" please comment after reading.
Please read and respond to the three questions below. Please comment or respond to at least...
Please read and respond to the three questions below. Please comment or respond to at least two of your classmates in addition to your initial post. Do not forget to cite your sources. 1. Under what conditions of bond issuance does a discount on bonds payable arise? Under what conditions of bond issuance does a premium on bonds payable arise? 2. How should discount on bonds payable be reported on the financial statements? Premium on bonds payable? 3. What are...
Analyze the income statement and explain what we can learn about the company from reading the income statement.
2015 2016Sales 3,432,000 5,834,400COGS 2,864,000 4,980,000Other expenses 340,000 720,000Analyze the income statement and explain what we can learn about the company from reading the income statement.Deprec. 18,900 116,960total op. costs 3,222,900 5,816,960EBIT 209,100. 17,440Int. expense 62,500 176,000pre tax earnings. 146,600. (158,560)taxes (40%) 58,640 (63,424)Net Income. 87,960 (95,136)
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT