In: Economics
Plastics, Inc. and Joe's Canoe Shack both operate businesses located on the river. Plastics, Inc. dumps pollution into the river, which results in fewer canoe rentals for Joe. The marginal cost of cleaning up the pollution is $20,000 for Plastics, Inc. Joe estimates a reduction in pollution will lead to a marginal benefit of $13,000.
a. If Joe owns the rights to the river, which of the following is the most likely outcome?
Below is a set of projects aimed at cleaning up a city's recreational areas. Determine whether the city should undertake the cleanup effort. Assume the city has enough money in its budget to undertake all projects.
Project | Marginal Cost | Marginal Benefit | Clean Up? |
North Park | $12,000 | $15,000 | (Click to select) Yes No |
Upper River Beach | 7,000 | 4,000 | (Click to select) Yes No |
South Shore | 21,000 | 29,000 | (Click to select) No Yes |
Green Creek | 2,000 | 1,400 | (Click to select) Yes No |
Plastics will use its property rights to continue polluting.
Plastics will pay Joe $17000 to pollute.
Joe will pay Plastics $17000 not to pollute.
Joe will enforce his property rights and not allow Plastics to pollute.
b. If Plastics, Inc. owns the rights to the river, which of the following is the most likely outcome?
Joe will enforce his property rights and not allow Plastics to pollute.
Joe will pay Plastics $17000 not to pollute.
Plastics will use its property rights to continue polluting.
Plastics will pay Joe $17000 to pollute.
Project | Marginal Cost | Marginal Benefit | Net benefit(Marginal benefit-marginal cost)(in dollars) | Clean Up? |
North Park | $12,000 | $15,000 | 3000 (15000-12000) | Yes |
Upper River Beach | 7,000 | 4,000 | -3000 (4000-7000) | No |
South Shore | 21,000 | 29,000 | 8000 (29000-21000) | Yes |
Green Creek | 2,000 | 1,400 | -600 (1400-2000) | No |
The city would undertake the cleanup effort in projects where net benefit is positive.
Marginal cost of cleaning up the pollution for Plastics, Inc. = $20,000
Marginal benefit of Joe for reduction in pollution = $13,000.
a. If Joe owns the rights to the river, Plastics will pay Joe $17000 so that pollute.
In this scenario, Plastic will gain $3000 (20000-17000) and Joe wil receive an incremental benefit of $4000 (17000-13000)
Explanation: Though Joe has legal claims, here, a good offer make both parties win.
b.If Plastics, Inc. owns the rights to the river, Plastics will use its property rights to continue polluting.
Explanation: Plastic will use the legal claims it possesses before any economic options.