Question

In: Physics

This question arose in a seminar today about the solar wind... This is my vagueish understanding...

This question arose in a seminar today about the solar wind...

This is my vagueish understanding of the problem - please correct if you see errors!

The 'classical' picture of atmospheric electricity is that the Earth as a whole is neutral, but that thunderstorms maintain a voltage of around +300kV at the electrosphere with respect to the Earth's surface, with a current of around 1 kA slowly discharging around 500 kC of total charge separation. The solar wind is supposed to neutralise any net charge that might be there between the Earth as a whole and the solar wind.

However, positive and negative charges in the solar wind are differently trapped in the van Allen belts, from which they can then descend to the Earth's atmosphere, which implies that a net charge can be developed due to this differential leakage. This begs the question of whether there are any estimates of the total net charge. I've hunted in the literature but have found little useful material other than Dolezalek's 1988 paper: http://www.springerlink.com/content/u057683112l148x5/

Can anyone offer an explanation, or point me to some more relevant papers?

Solutions

Expert Solution

However, positive and negative charges in the solar wind are differently trapped in the van Allen belts, from which they can then descend to the Earth's atmosphere, which implies that a net charge can be developed due to this differential leakage. This begs the question of whether there are any estimates of the total net charge. I've hunted in the literature but have found little useful material other than Dolezalek's 1988 paper: http://www.springerlink.com/content/u057683112l148x5/

Right I see an important misunderstanding here! Positive and negative charges from the solar wind are NOT differently trapped. When we talk about the van Allen belts we are talking about high energy particles (MeV); low energy particles are still there, though in the majority of the outer belt the density is very low. Its fair to say that the electrons and protons go through different acceleration processes (its also worth noting that there are two inner belts, a positive and a negative that overlap as well as sitting on the region of the magnetosphere called the plasmasphere - a cold dense plasma that extends to about 4 Earth radii)

Some of the same waves that scatter relativistic waves into the loss cone and cause them to precipitate (electromagnetic ion-cyclotron waves) also scatter lower energy protons into the atmosphere. Over very short time scales there will be a charge difference, but on average quasi-neutrality will be maintained.

When precipitation occurs you have to remember that you are dealing with the ionosphere which is itself a plasma and therefore quasi-neutral. Current systems do form due to the collisions of ions with the neutral atmosphere. In the D-region, where MeV electrons deposit when they precipitate (in fact they cause extra ionisation and extend the D-layer downwards) there is a whole mixed bag of high collisions, attachment processes and recombination processes involving all sorts of complex ion-chemistry, the less energetic protons will deposit at higher altitudes so there would be a small charge gains in different regions but due to high conductivity in the E layer (120 km) and possible current systems that would not be the case for long. *

Now the atmosphere stuff is not my bag but you might like to go and look at the work of Dr. Martin Fullerkrug of the university of Bath who does some very cool work on sprites and whatnot.

Hope that helps

*I am not saying that exactly equal numbers of protons and electrons precipitate at a given moment but looking at the system over even relatively small time-scales the net charge would be damn close to zero


Related Solutions

Wind and solar energy are “clean” ways to generate electricity, although we tend to forget about...
Wind and solar energy are “clean” ways to generate electricity, although we tend to forget about pollution created in the production and disposal of equipment and we may overestimate their value due to grid - related requirements . Discuss both factors and how we might structure policies that would lead to efficient investment decisions.. (An answer would discuss the intermittency of these power sources and the need for (ii) more expensive transmission systems ; (iii)) need for more back -...
Based on my understanding of nursing today, Healthy People 2020 could be used by me in...
Based on my understanding of nursing today, Healthy People 2020 could be used by me in many ways to make a difference in the health and wellness of people in my area. The area that I intend to specialize in once I am a Registered Nurse is mental health. Healthy People 2020 has a lot of information regarding mental health. It can be used as additional resources for people who are seeking information regarding mental health. Based upon readings and...
57) The advantages of solar or wind energy are (as opposed to fossil fuels): A)they are...
57) The advantages of solar or wind energy are (as opposed to fossil fuels): A)they are non polluting   B)the source of the energy is free C)they are found in nearly every country to some degree   D)localized production is possible E)all of the above 58) The Endangered Species Act of 1973 authorized the United States Federal Government to protect organisms listed as endangered (in danger of extinction) as well as protecting the habitats of those listed organisms. A)True             B)False 59)The idea that one's lifestyle...
Name four ways to improve the integration of variable wind and solar resources.
Name four ways to improve the integration of variable wind and solar resources.
At the rate at which the Sun is losing mass in the solar wind, how many...
At the rate at which the Sun is losing mass in the solar wind, how many years will it take the Sun to lose as much mass as Uranus? It will take ___ × 108 years.
The solar wind consists of protons, electrons and other heavier irons and they have velocities of...
The solar wind consists of protons, electrons and other heavier irons and they have velocities of several hundred km per second. Moving charged particles experience a force when in an external magnetic field. The Earth's magnetic field at the equator has a value of approximately 3 x 10-5 T and is directed to the north. This field strength extends into the space above the earth. Consider a solar wind proton moving at 5 x 105 m/s that approaches the earth...
I need a answer to my professors question about my discussion post My Post 1) What...
I need a answer to my professors question about my discussion post My Post 1) What types are protected? Under the National Labor Relation Act, an employee's right to strike is a considered as a critical component of the right to organize. But to ensure balance this right is not without limitations. As per Section 7 of NLRA only Certain strikes qualify as protected activity. These recognized strikes are: ·         Unfair labor practice strikes, which protest employers illegal activities. ·        ...
note that hydroelectric, wind, and solar power has a marginal cost of essentially zero. Because the...
note that hydroelectric, wind, and solar power has a marginal cost of essentially zero. Because the price of electricity is determined by demand and the highest marginal cost source used to meet that demand, renewables are currently quite profitable once the up-front costs are accounted for. Imagine now a world in which the electricity grid consists only of renewable energy sources (likely paired with energy storage systems). The likely marginal cost of an additional megawatt-hour of electricity would be zero....
The question arose as to whether gender might be an effect modifier of this association. When...
The question arose as to whether gender might be an effect modifier of this association. When gender was assessed, the data looked like the following: Women Men Accident No Accident Accident No Accident Driver's Ed 10 50 60 120 No Driver's Ed 40 50 40 80 Perform the appropriate calculations to test for effect modification. Interpret your results.
Renewable sources of energy include photovoltaic, solar thermal electric, wind, geothermal, and hydroelectric. of these five...
Renewable sources of energy include photovoltaic, solar thermal electric, wind, geothermal, and hydroelectric. of these five types of energy, which one shows the greatest promise for economic viability over the next 10 years. why do you say this, and what obstacles, if any must be overcome to make this a reality?
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT