In: Finance
Property Assumptions
Purchase Price: $12,500,000
Year 1 Potential Rental Income (PRI): $1,650,000
PGI annual growth rate: 3%
Annual Vacancy and Credit Loss (VCL): 5%
Over next 6yrs.
Year 1 operating expenses (OER): (Oper. Expense Ratio) 35%
OPEX annual growth rate (after year 1): 2%
Sales Price : Terminal Cap Rate .09
Capitalize 6th yr. NOI
Sales Costs: Commissions 3% of Sales Price
Anticipated holding period 5 years
Maximum loan-to-value (LTV) ratio: 75%
Interest Rate: 5.25%
Amortization Period: 20 years
Payments per year: 12
Investors’ Hurdle Rate (unleveraged) 12%
Investors’ Hurdle Rate (leveraged) 15%
The Excel formulas for the solution are provided towards the end of the solution.
| Amount | % | |
| Potential Rental Income (Year 1) | 1650000 | |
| PGI growth rate | 3% | |
| Vacancy and Credit Losses | 5% | |
| Operating Expense Ratio (Year 1) | 35% | |
| OPEX growth rate | 2% |
1. For year 1, Operating Expense = OER*(PRI - VCL)
For subsequent years, (Operating Expense)t = (Operating Expense)t-1 * (1+OPEX growth rate)
Similarly, (Property Rental Income)t = (Property Rental Income)t-1 * (1+PGI growth rate)
| 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | |
| Potential Rental Income (PRI) | 1650000 | 1699500 | 1750485 | 1803000 | 1857090 | 1912802 | |
| Vacancy and Credit Losses (VCL) | 82500 | 84975 | 87524 | 90150 | 92854 | 95640 | |
| Operating Expenses | 548625 | 559598 | 570789 | 582205 | 593849 | 605726 | |
| Net Operating Income (NOI) | 1018875 | 1054928 | 1092171 | 1130644 | 1170386 | 1211436 | |
| Operating Expense Ratio | 35.00% | 34.66% | 34.32% | 33.99% | 33.66% | 33.33% |
2. (Sales Price)5 = NOI6/Terminal Cap Rate
Sales Costs Commissions = 3%*(Sales Price)5
| Terminal Cap Rate | 9% | |
| Sales Price | 13460398 | |
| Sales Costs: Commissions | 403812 | 3% |
Terminal Value of the Investment = Net Sales proceeds = Sales Price-Sales Commission


UNLEVERAGED PROPERTY
| 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | |
| Purchase Price | -12500000 | |||||
| NOI | 1018875 | 1054928 | 1092171 | 1130644 | 1170386 | |
| Terminal Property Value | 13056586 | |||||
| Net Cash flows (unleveraged) | -12500000 | 1018875 | 1054928 | 1092171 | 1130644 | 14226971 |
| NPV (unleveraged) | -1180612 | |||||
| IRR (unleveraged) | 9.43% |
Net Cash flow in the 5th year would be the sum of Net Operating Income (NOI) plus the (Sales Price-Sales Commission) received on selling the property at the end of 5th year.
3. LEVERAGED PROPERTY
Purchase Price = 12,500,000
Loan principal amount = LTV ratio * Purchase Price
Monthly EMI = PMT(Monthly Interest Rate, No. of Periods, PV)
Monthly Interest Rate = 5.25%/12 = 0.438%
No. of Periods = 20*12 = 240
PV = Loan principal amount
| LTV ratio | 75% | |
| Loan principal amount | 1237500 | |
| Interest Rate | 5.25% | |
| Term period (years) | 20 | |
| Payments per year | 12 | |
| Monthly EMI | 8338.82 |
| 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | |
| Purchase Price | -12500000 | |||||
| NOI | 1018875 | 1054928 | 1092171 | 1130644 | 1170386 | |
| Annual EMIs | 100066 | 100066 | 100066 | 100066 | 100066 | |
| Annual Cash flows (leveraged) | 918809 | 954862 | 992105 | 1030578 | 1070320 | |
| Terminal Property Value | 13056586 | |||||
| Net Cash flows (levered) | -12500000 | 918809 | 954862 | 992105 | 1030578 | 14126905 |
| NPV (leveraged) | -2713892 | |||||
| IRR (leveraged) | 8.65% |
4. No, it is not recommended to purchase this property, as the NPV of this investment is negative in either case.