Question

In: Finance

does higher wages means lower productivity and more competition from outside the USA

does higher wages means lower productivity and more competition from outside the USA

Solutions

Expert Solution

Amazon recently made headlines by announcing that it would voluntarily increase its minimum hourly wage to $15. With a federal minimum wage of only $7.25, this pledge might seem like a curious decision — especially for a company as laser-focused on cost containment as Amazon. But thinking only about the costs involved in raising wages misses a key issue: pay hikes can also boost workplace productivity.

Given Amazon’s well-deserved reputation as a data-driven (and long-term oriented) company, you can bet that Amazon’s management team has done the analysis and figured out that paying employees more is, from a business perspective, more benefit than cost. They’re not the first company to make a decision like this — most notably, Walmart set a minimum wage of $11 earlier in 2018 — and we hope others come to realize that paying workers more can be a matter of enlightened self-interest.

In fact, the company has been accused of being too self-serving in its minimum wage hike — concerns arose nearly immediately after its announcement that the increase might be financed by cuts to bonuses and benefits that would leave workers no better off than before.

In our own research, we’ve explored the impact that minimum wages can have on businesses, as well as the ways in which higher wages can motivate employees and spur productivity. We’re fascinated by companies’ motivations to do prosocial (and also antisocial) things. And looking at Amazon’s recent announcement, there’s reason to think that a pay hike would be good both for Amazon’s employees and its bottom line.

Ultimately, Amazon may very well benefit from increasing its minimum wage, even if it does end up paying its workers more. Here’s why:

First, higher wages allow firms to attract and retain better employees (assuming competitors don’t follow suit and raise their wages as well). But there is an important — and often overlooked — second effect. Paying wages that are above the market rate (known within economics as “efficiency wages”) can also be an important motivating force for your existing employee base. The intuition is straightforward: higher wages makes a job more desirable. This leads to a larger applicant pool waiting to take over when openings occur, and makes it easier to replace a slacker employee. It also means that workers have more to lose by slacking off — who cares if you’re fired from a $7.25 an hour job, but where else will you find somewhere that pays $15 per hour?

The concept of efficiency wages is an old idea, dating back at least to Henry Ford’s introduction of the “five dollar day” in 1914, at a time when the daily wage at manufacturing plants near his Highland Park factory was $2.30. Ford himself called it his finest cost-cutting move, because of the boost to productivity that came as a result.

There’s good reason to think that Jeff Bezos’s $15 per hour will be as successful as Ford’s $5 a day.

The manner in which Amazon announced its $15 wages is likely to boost the productivity gains coming from the wage hikes. How so? Beyond the classic notion of efficiency wages — I work harder because I fear losing a better-paying job — above-market wages can lead to a second productivity gain driven by employees’ innate sense of reciprocity. Research (including our own work) has found that when a company gives unexpected pay increases, workers often reciprocate by working harder than is required (even if they don’t worry about getting fired). And, what better way to signal your good intentions and concern for workers than through a flamboyant public announcement of a substantial pay raise.

Finally, some of Amazon’s high wage PR may be directed at government officials. With a president who has taken to bashing the company and its leader, it can’t hurt to look like the good guy once in a while. And if governments at the state and city-level make good on their pledges to raise the minimum wage locally, Amazon will be paying $15 an hour sometime soon anyway — so why not get out in front of the issue now?

Of course, there remain open questions about the implementation of Amazon’s new plan: Will employee benefits (like annual bonuses) be rolled back to finance the wage increase? Will some contract workers be excluded from it? We hope not, and we hope that Amazon is sincere about meaningfully improving wages for their lower wage workers. Furthermore, the law of unintended consequences being what it is, we’re sure that not even Amazon will anticipate all of the effects of higher wages — one story that followed close on the heels of the announcement described brewing resentment among incumbent Amazon workers that newbies would get the same high wage as more senior employees.

And, to be clear, if increasing wages turns out to be a profitable decision that does not take away from our support for Amazon’s decision. We applaud cases in which companies do right by their employees, the environment, and society in general. And if Amazon ends up making more money as a result, that’s all to the greater good.


Related Solutions

the higher the anticipated inflation rate, ... a. the more workers will ask for in wages...
the higher the anticipated inflation rate, ... a. the more workers will ask for in wages and the more firms will agree to pay b.the more workers will ask for in wages and the less firms will agree to pay c. the less workers will ask for in wages and the less firms will agree to pay d. the higher the real wage increases offered by firm e. the higher the real wage increases asked for by workers
1.USA is getting older. In retirement, do families have a higher or lower income than other...
1.USA is getting older. In retirement, do families have a higher or lower income than other parts of their life? So more retirees increases/decreases poverty? 2.Many lament the crumbling American family. Do single parent families experience more/less poverty? So more single parent families increases/decreases poverty? 3.Poverty is often counted by household. Typically are poor families smaller/bigger than wealthy ones? 4.If poverty were measured by person, would the poverty rate increase/decrease compared to measuring by households? 5.Poverty means low income, but...
1- Competition among entrepreneurs will result in Select one: a. Workers getting paid higher wages than...
1- Competition among entrepreneurs will result in Select one: a. Workers getting paid higher wages than otherwise due to better alternative employment opportunities available. b. Consumers paying higher prices than otherwise, due to increased cost. c. Entrepreneurs making higher profits than otherwise due to increased efficiency. d. Less product innovation than otherwise due to increased cost pressures and lower research budgets.
how does the classical model explain a lower period of lower output and rising prices (higher...
how does the classical model explain a lower period of lower output and rising prices (higher inflation)?
suspects that when the temperature outside is higher more failures occur. data for 18 days and...
suspects that when the temperature outside is higher more failures occur. data for 18 days and the temperatures in C temp failure 21.9 13 22.8 12 17.4 16 21.9 17 22.7 15 19.8 16 19.5 17 18.1 15 21.8 16 22.5 16 18.6 15 21.7 16 20.5 17 19.3 16 19.0 16 21.1 14 20.2 17 18.5 14 Is there evidence that more computer failures occur during hotter weather? 1. Null hypothesis ? 2. linear regression using R and interpret
1. High insurance deductible usually means: A lower premiums B Higher premiums C No difference in...
1. High insurance deductible usually means: A lower premiums B Higher premiums C No difference in premium D you are willing to take on more risk 2. Worker's comp will still pay a claim if the worker was intoxicated at the time of the accident. A True B False 3. On a depreciating asset most likely the insurance premium would be higher for A A replacement cost policy B A value based policy C This make no difference D High...
What is an infectious dose? Would a more virulent organism have a higher or lower infectious...
What is an infectious dose? Would a more virulent organism have a higher or lower infectious dose? What can affect the infectious dose of a microbe?
How does advertising impact market structure? Does it create more competition or impede competition among companies...
How does advertising impact market structure? Does it create more competition or impede competition among companies participating in the market? Explain and argue for both sides of the arguments and give examples for your arguments. Do we need any rules and regulations for manner in which advertising is taken up by companies in our economy and explain why?
This question relates to standing waves. A) Does a closed pipe have a higher or lower...
This question relates to standing waves. A) Does a closed pipe have a higher or lower fundamental frequency than an open pipe of the same length? B) If the length of an open tube is 0.8 m, experimentally find the: fundamental frequency and the frequencies of the third and fifth harmonic. C) We have only addressed the variables of length, wave speed, harmonic number and frequency. These seem to be adequate to fully describe the frequency of a standing wave....
2. Before we discussed how the higher LFPR of women has led to more competition in...
2. Before we discussed how the higher LFPR of women has led to more competition in labor markets, leading to a higher need for education. In this week’s reading, we learn that competitive factors in labor markets is a key condition leading to the result MPL=W/P=real wage. Discuss the role of technological progress post-WWII, and its impact on real wages, the competitiveness of labor markets, trends in education, and wage disparities. Note : Refer from book MACROECONOMICS, by N Gregory...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT