Question

In: Physics

Fermilab seems to have ruled out monopoles with mass less than 850 GeV, but I have...

Fermilab seems to have ruled out monopoles with mass less than 850 GeV, but I have seen some estimates of the mass thought to be in the order of up to 1018 GeV, which, of course, would make them undetectable in any accelerators. By 2013, the LHC is scheduled to reach up to 14 TeV. The only disputed sighting of a cosmic ray produced magnetic monopole was in 1982 when Blas Cabrera reported discovering one (Valentine event monopole). This has never been duplicated. CERN has set up the Monopole and Exotics Detector MOEDAL. Other experiments set up to detect them are the Antarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna--ANITA, and the Antarctic Muon And Neutrino Detection Array, aka AMANDA. While both of these detected neutrinos, neither detected magnetic monopoles (looking for Cerenkov radiation produced by products of monopole interaction). Another method of detection is to look for induced current in a superconducting ring when a monopole passes through. Joseph Polchinski called the existence of monopoles

Solutions

Expert Solution

Polchinski didn't imply anything about the lightness of the monopoles. You are overinterpreting what he said: his statement was an in-principle statement by a theorist. Just to be sure, the MoEDAL collaboration has overinterpreted him, too: he has never suggested that an experiment of their kind will find the beast. Still, it's very important to know whether such qualitatively different particles exist even if we think it's very likely that they won't be directly detected in the near (or far) future. Most of the top contemporary state-of-the-art theoretical physics deals with objects that will probably never be detected by direct experiments, for obvious financial and technological limitations.

Directly experimentally, the lower bound on the mass is just 500 GeV or so, but when some theory is wisely added, the mass is pretty much required to be exponentially higher than the TeV scale. In particular, some kind of unification seems necessary to allow the magnetic monopoles, and unification such as GUT can only appear at very high scales, such as the GUT scale of GeV: that's where the electromagnetic U(1) may be embedded in a larger group that allows a topologically nontrivial solution (the SU(2) of the weak interactions is not enough - it doesn't contain the hypercharge which has to be twisted as well). So it's unlikely that direct detection succeeds. Inflation has probably diluted the concentration of those massive magnetic monopoles to a very tiny number.


Related Solutions

d Since the spokes of a bicycle wheel have much less mass than the rim, the...
d Since the spokes of a bicycle wheel have much less mass than the rim, the wheel can be modeled as a cylindrical hoop of mass 1.90 kg and radius 0.6 m. This wheel rotates without friction about a vertical axis perpendicular to the disk and through its center. Standing on the rim is a kitten of mass 1.00 kg (the kitten can be modeled as a point mass). The wheel (with the kitten standing on it) rotates with an...
Consider the probability that less than 14 out of 157 people have been in a car...
Consider the probability that less than 14 out of 157 people have been in a car accident. Assume the probability that a given person has been in a car accident is 11%.
consider the probability that less than 16 out of 151 people have been in a car...
consider the probability that less than 16 out of 151 people have been in a car accident. assume the probability that a given person has been in a car accident is 12%. Approximate the probability using the normal distribution. Round to four decimal places.
Consider the probability that no less than 21 out of 329 students will not pass their...
Consider the probability that no less than 21 out of 329 students will not pass their college placement exams. Choose the best description of the area under the normal curve that would be used to approximate binomial probability. OPTIONS ARE: Area to the right of 20.5 Area to the right of 21.5 Area to left of 20.5 Area to left of 21.5 Area between 20.5 and 21.5
Consider the probability that no less than 21 out of 329 students will not pass their...
Consider the probability that no less than 21 out of 329 students will not pass their college placement exams. Choose the best description of the area under the normal curve that would be used to approximate binomial probability. OPTIONS ARE: Area to the right of 20.5 Area to the right of 21.5 Area to left of 20.5 Area to left of 21.5 Area between 20.5 and 21.5
Consider the probability that no less than 88 out of 158 computers will not crash in...
Consider the probability that no less than 88 out of 158 computers will not crash in a day. Assume the probability that a given computer will not crash in a day is 57%. Approximate the probability using the normal distribution. Round your answer to four decimal places.
I was wondering, is there more or less water on the Earth than there used to...
I was wondering, is there more or less water on the Earth than there used to be a million years ago?
I have posted this earlier, but it seems that the code part was cutoff, therefore, this...
I have posted this earlier, but it seems that the code part was cutoff, therefore, this is re post with full code. In the program the "case: 'C'" doesn't seem to function correctly, We were told to write a book tracking program, and it takes inputs and once all the book info such as ISBN, date, author, course number, etc are put in then input, then we can print them out, by using the print functions that are defined in...
Consider the probability that no less than 92 out of 157 registered voters will vote in...
Consider the probability that no less than 92 out of 157 registered voters will vote in the presidential election. Assume the probability that a given registered voter will vote in the presidential election is 64% Approximate the probability using the normal distribution. Round your answer to four decimal places.
Write a program that prints out all numbers, less than or equal to 10,000,000, that are...
Write a program that prints out all numbers, less than or equal to 10,000,000, that are evenly divisible by all numbers between 5 and 15 (inclusive). Do not use any libraries besides stdio.h. Need it in 10 minutes, please.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT